Menuhin plays Saint-Saëns Violin Concerto No. 3 - 1st mvt
Loading...
Link to this comment:
Top Comments
Video Responses
All Comments (55)
-
He Melts My Heart!
-
Amazing Violinist!
-
Great. However, he was a tad out of tune.
-
This is really the later Menuhin sound. Like it or not: Menuhin was a unique musician who played in a very genuin sort of style. He was Menuhin; we can't ignore his impact one contemporary violinists. He is a legent.
-
i like this version, but my favorite version of this piece is definitely either chee-yun's or zino franscescatti's.
-
he has annoying intonation problems all over the place. and I don't like his expression in a lot of places either
-
@FrankCoffman I agree marcovici is amazing, but still prefer Menuhin-he is definitely a genius
-
Just listen to the way Silvia Marcovici attacks the strings and makes them scream. Whoa! She is amazing.
-
Menuhin is fine, but not exciting. I love this violin concerto. I've listened to different interpretations of it. He plays it in an ordinary way, nothing special.
Silvia Marcovici plays it with verve and energy -- like she really LOVES it and BELIEVES in it and LIVES in it. Menuhin just goes from note to note in a correct way. Ho-hum. After listening to Silvia Marcovici, I can't listen to Menuhin going through the motions.... yawn....
10:59Menuhin plays Saint-Saëns Violin Concerto No. 3...by marking1915,450 views
- 9:43Saint Saëns Violin Concerto No 3 Op 61 1st movby musicFTE23,605 views
- 10:55Violon - Julia Fischer - Concerto N° 3 in B M...by filometti122,949 views
- 10:15Camille Saint Saens Cello Concerto No 1 in A mi...by xeygarz159,757 views
- 9:17Kyung Wha Chung - Saint Saens Violin Concerto N...by violinmusicfan15,204 views
- 9:21Violon - Anne Sophie Mutter - Concerto in D Ma...by filometti112,256 views
- 9:10Saint Saens Violin Concerto #3 1st Mvt.by Annfontanella118,705 views
- 8:53Violon - Julia Fischer - Concerto N° 3 in B M...by filometti119,385 views
- 5:49Vengerov - Saint-Saensby PPanncho151,795 views
- 1:22THE GREATEST VIOLINARTIST - YEHUDI MENUHINby aaharry5524,938 views
- 6:46Saint Saens - Violin Concerto n. 3 - 3 mov. par...by emmbaldini8,391 views
- 9:07Bruch Violin Concerto #1 mvt.1 - Itzhak Perlmanby se724153,724 views
- 10:24Saint-Saens Violin Concerto No. 3 in b minor, m...by hegedu86,502 views
- 6:52Saint-Saens Violin Concerto No 3 - iby parnasm31,025 views
- 9:25Zino Francescatti - Saint-Saëns Violin Concerto...by UltimateViolin44,456 views
- 6:45Arthur Grumiaux plays Svendsen's Romanceby violim3,046 views
- 8:59Saint-Saens - Introduction & Rondo Capriccioso ...by mixailaggelos2004469,304 views
- 8:16Saint-Saëns, Camille violin concerto no.3 mvt2by HenriVieuxtemps3,179 views
- 9:00Camille Saint-Saëns - Violin Concerto No. 3 in ...by CharlePhilippeLafont4,817 views
Anything could have ruined this recording quality, but before you go judging Menuhin, take into account that he was one of the greatest musicians who ever lived, and that his interpretation is a valid one. While it may not be YOUR taste, don't go calling it rubbish, for that lacks respect for yourself, and the performer. Grow up.
tlcooper93 1 year ago 20
Every violinist has his/her own way of interpreting the piece. If you're a real musician, you'd respect and even learn something from it.
redmilkk 1 month ago