Rachmaninoff - Etude Tableaux, Op 33, No 3 - Timothy Nguyen
Uploader Comments (RachmaninoffGuy)
All Comments (27)
-
@Aerovistae If you aren't already familiar with how a piece should be, you can learn to hear stuff like that with lots of ear training :)
-
man that F dominant chord at 1:39 is so classy. rachmaninoff is a boss
-
Crave?
-
good
-
Lovely :) I think people are being negative about your playing because they are jealous, do we all need to point out that he is not Argerich Horowitz or Richter? Unnecessary maybe. There was a nice emotion and calmness.
-
@motionmtn Roll the chord.
-
@hyperhavoc5 i actually am, but i can only learn by reading sheet music to see which keys to hit and listening to the song to know how it's supposed to sound. im completely tone deaf.
-
@Aerovistae You're obviously not a musician...
-
@nikkapfan how the helllll do you notice that? you are listening to this on a whole other level from what i am. i can't even tell the difference between an A and a B.
-
@CoolWJL Thats what I just said...
I should also point out that in b. 8, beat 3 of the opening C minor section (the brief ff climax), the upper note of the right-hand chord after the crotchet rest should be C, not A flat, creating another perfect-fifth "bell" chord. The problem with Dover is that they're cheap but often use unreliable editions. Congratulations and best wishes.
flibbertergibbet 2 years ago 3
Shame on Dover again (and myself for not finding it sooner). Thanks for the info!
RachmaninoffGuy 2 years ago 2
There are at least two videos of this piece on Youtube where the players make the same mistake. But it's not their fault, it's just a misprint, I guess.
In the fourth bar after "poco and poco agitato" indication an octave on E should be played on the third beat. They play C.
Therefore, the beauty of the climax becomes lost.
Listen to Lugansky here. He plays that correctly.
No offence.
nikkapfan 3 years ago 22
Wow, you're right! I'm ashamed to have not noticed this. The (erroneous) edition above is Dover.
RachmaninoffGuy 3 years ago