Can God be both Omnipotent and Omniscent?
Uploader Comments (theatheistguy)
Video Responses
All Comments (26)
-
@theatheistguy I don't believe in any kind of god.
-
he cannot be both because if he knows all then he is unable to change any of it. omniscience by its very nature rules out free will. a choice requires multiple options and omniscience only allows one.
-
@iGotStupidFlow no. if that's the case then why worship such a being?
-
@iGotStupidFlow no
-
@theatheistguy (Read my first comment first it goes with this one) And the reason for why you say all of these things are because you think. If there is a God, (when there Is God) he should be able to make all of these miracles, there should be no bad on Earth and all of those other things you claim to say is "proof". Well I can answer that-- And PLEASE PLEASE JUST SAY YES OR NO. Doesn't it make sense that the reason there is bad on this earth because God wanted to show the angels what Sin is?
I will pray for your sins.
sorrow128 1 month ago
@sorrow128 Why?
theatheistguy 1 month ago
The point is, if god knows when you are born what choices you are going to make, god knows if you are going to end up in heaven or hell at the point, before you live your life. Why then would he allow you to exist for the sole purpose of going to hell? Why wouldn't he kill you before you are doomed to hell?
As an individual you appear to have a choice at any moment but god already knows what the outcome is of every choice you are going to make. He knows this before you are born. Understand?
sigmata0 7 months ago
@sigmata0 Do you believe in that kind of god?
theatheistguy 7 months ago
If you knew that making a gun would lead to lots of pain and death, but you made it anyways, would you not be responsible for those deaths?
If you agree to this idea then God is the father of all sins.
kingkong8974 1 year ago 2
@kingkong8974 Ah but think of all the people who use guns (free will) and don't hurt anyone, are you going to take away their right to have a gun (free will)? /s
God could just have seen who was going to worship him anyway, create those souls, and off they go to worship him, no need for anyone to burn for eternity or even just suffer on earth.
theatheistguy 1 year ago