Liza Minnelli Le Jazz Hot
Uploader Comments (rosekelly)
Top Comments
-
Yes, fascinating to make the inevitable Julie/Liza comparison.
I hesitate to say it, but I don't think this particular arrangement of the song shows either off to her best advantage. Now if you want PERFECTION, you watch Julie in the original. She is the most appealing and talented entertainer of all time. Past, present and future. imHo, of course...;)
That is just one of the laws of the universe like gravity or procreation.
-
defenitley not as polished as Ms. Andrews
All Comments (67)
-
as this story revolves around the deceipt of a woman singer impersonating a man who can, as a woman impersonator sing such high notes that he blows all other female impersonators out of the water I really don't think it works with anyone who can't perform that trick...Julie could do it just, with some pre-recorded help, in 1995, but surely Liza couldn't, and Julie's other replacement, Rachel Welch never hit any notes at all...might be fun with Chenoweth though :-)
-
If I were Liza's mgr, I wouldn't have let her do this number. It's dreadful! JA puts her to shame. Loss had her good performances, but this isn't one of them!
-
I like Liza, but compared to Julie Andrews, this version sucks!
-
liza is just wonderful. the song was written for julies range and the changed it up for liza both are wonderful julie has a better range but lizas dancing is far better
-
liza is great in everything she does. Was the rest of the broadway show filmed. If so please put it on youtube please. Thankyou
-
Its true that Julie Andrews did it great. But Liza is also great.
-
@emmadilemmasings yes I do know that too.
-
@strawberrycurrant Actually she filled in for Julie because Julie became very sick and required surgery and hasn't been able to sing since.
-
Please stop comparing Julie and Liza. I love them both but they are different from each other. Yes they are both GREAT AND ENORMOUSLY TALENTED why can't people just accept that. Liza did her best during this run. please remember that she filled in for Julie because this is an extremely taxing show and the lady needed a break. Love 2:20-2:30 best part ever.
-
@charlexington "The most appealing and talented entertainer of all time, past present and future" isn't Ms Julie Andrews, or ANY broadway star for that matter, iMHo. Numerous other soprano, tenor, baritone, mezzo, bass, contralto, stage actor/actress of the past century TRUMP over all of them. At any time
They both had the same surgery
rosekelly 2 years ago
Liza really brought her own to this... I love julie but I love the way the tempo was changed from julies version... after the the guy sang liza kept the same beat going... julie slowed it down a bit too much...Liza liza liza! But love you too julie x
rosekelly 3 years ago
liza better than julie by far. The dance steps were changed by Liza....more Fosse. Better by far I'LL SAY!
rosekelly 5 years ago