Uploaded by smalin on Mar 20, 2009
FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions)
Q: Can I get free sheet music for this piece?
A: Yes, you can download the score shown in the video from here:
http://www.musanim.com/pdf/BeethovenMoonlightSonata_mvt1.pdf
Q: What do the colors in the bar-graph score mean?
A: The colors indicate the "pitch class" of the notes; that is, every C# is a certain color (blue), every E is a certain color (olive green), etc. The piece is in the key of C# minor, so there's lots of blue and green, especially at the beginning and end. The choice of colors is based on the "circle of fifths," which you can read about here:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circle_of_fifths
This method of coloring notes is described more here:
http://www.musanim.com/mam/pfifth.htm
Because this form of coloring reflects tonality, the places where the piece moves into another key are easily visible; here's a picture of the whole piece:
http://www.musanim.com/img/FuerEliseWholePiece.gif
BTW, the colors are more distinct in the high-quality version of the video.
Q: What did this sheet music look like back in Beethoven's time?
A: Here is a facsimile of the first edition, printed in 1802.
http://www.musanim.com/pdf/BeethovenMoonlightFirstEdition.pdf
Q: What do the light/dark areas in the bar-graph score show?
A: They show the effect of the damper pedal.
Q: What do the x's in the score mean?
A: Those are double-sharps. A sharp goes up one semitone (F to F-sharp) and a double sharp goes up two semitones (F to F-double-sharp, same key on the piano as G).
Q: Who is playing? Who are you? How long have you been playing the piano?
A: See this:
http://www.musanim.com/faq/whoareyou.html
Q: Is there a way I could make the bar-graph scores myself?
A: The Music Animation Machine MIDI file player will generate this display; you can get the (Windows) software here:
http://www.musanim.com/player/
There are lots of places on the web where you can get MIDI files; I usually go to the Classical Archives site first:
http://www.classicalarchives.com/
Q: You said "it's well documented that different synesthetes have different associations." Where is this documented? I read on Wikipedia that "synesthetes, as a group, share significant preferences for the color of each letter."
A: It's true that there are some patterns in the associations synesthetes make between colors and letters (or numerals, pitches, etc.), but the Wikipedia article is misleading in suggesting that there's anything approaching a unanimity of opinion. On this page, I'm collecting some references and pointers to research so that you can draw your own conclusions based on the data:
http://www.musanim.com/synesthesia/
Q: Could you please do a MAM video of _________?
A: Please read this:
http://www.musanim.com/all/MAMRequests.html
.
-
9,180 likes, 178 dislikes
-
Artist: Ludwig van Beethoven
-
As Seen On:
Olhares.com
Link to this comment:
Uploader Comments (smalin)
Video Responses
All Comments (3,664)
-
Thanks for uploading this! I'm learning it right now for a performance! This is my favorite piece by Beethoven!
ramunicorno721 1 day ago
-
Cheers for uploading this...I'm attempting to learn it at the moment and this is really usful :)
macdem1000 2 days ago
-
@RianeBane you should really study up on the works of not only beethoven, but also many others that are being misinterpreted... You are also wrong about it being named moonlight sonata... that came much later...
eyePWNThisChannel 2 days ago
-
is this song hard to play
Catfishhunter2013 2 days ago
-
oh my god.. great... i want to learning how to play a piano like you man...
you is a inspiration for me.. thanks..
adannalan 3 days ago
-
this gave us i i want you shes so heavy by the beatles!
LtDrg35 5 days ago
-
I wish my keyboard had more keys
hkdxforsaken 1 week ago
-
This plus RainyMood? ~love~
JeannieGirl1357 1 week ago
23 videos

Romantic
6:35Franck, Violin Sonataby smalin1,018 views
3:31Vivaldi, Spring, Allegro (Four Seasons)by smalin5,308 views
7:39Mozart, Requiem in D minor, 1. Requiem/Kyrieby smalin7,920 views
12:24Beethoven, Symphony 6, 1st movementby smalin11,122 views
8:54Mozart - Requiemby madhammu17,072,623 views
3:48Beethoven - Fur Elise [100% Speed]by ic3zz862,070,077 views
8:02Homeless Boy Steals The Talent Showby inspirationbygod19,706,717 views
11:26Mozart K545 Sonata in C major (complete)by BachScholar233,678 views
3:16Bach, Cello Suite No. 1, 1st mvt. (showing bowing)by smalin27,303 views
5:28Moonlight Sonata - classical guitarby michaellucarelli5,474,256 views
3:22Beethoven - Fur Elise (Piano)by zelcadence583,723 views
3:08Mozart - Turkish March [100% Speed]by ic3zz862,585,060 views
4:29Hardest song on piano ever! (Circus Galop)by charmander121222,120,697 views
9:50Beethoven - Moonlight Sonata [Advanced Piano Tu...by youcanplayit856,424 views
0:46How to Play the Moonlight Sonataby sesameseed77283,601 views
7:34Wilhelm Kempff plays Beethoven's Moonlight Sona...by popololopopolo8,521,114 views
7:38Beethoven, 5th Symphonyby smalin3,009,345 views
4:07Mozart, Marriage of Figaro, overture (bar-graph...by musanim109,232 views
5:51Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - Piano Concerto No. 21...by poloshia21,681,145 views
- Loading more suggestions...



Did you learn specifically to play with a 2-4-5 fingering in your right hand at the beginning (and other random locations), or is that what was more comfortable with you? Were you told that the thumb would produce too much of an accent to use a 1-2-4 (or 1-3-5) fingering? I personally find it easier to start with 1-2-4, just because I use it later once the melody comes in. But otherwise, you sounded wonderful. :)
goodnitemama 1 week ago
@goodnitemama I'm not thinking about my fingers (let alone what fingering I'm using) when I'm playing a piece like this; I'm just thinking about the sound of the music. My last piano lesson was more than forty years ago, and I developed most of my technique on my own after that, so it wasn't a matter of being told what to do, but rather of trying things and listening critically to the result. The technical part is all pretty much unconscious now.
smalin 1 week ago
@smalin
great playing and i have a problem as an amateur pianist
i cannot control top of my left thumb. so it becomes hard to play octaves or even to play arpeggios. do you have that problem as well?
MrChopiano 2 weeks ago
@MrChopiano No, I don't have a problem with my left thumb. I have played a lot of contrapuntal music (e.g. during my twenties, I played the fugues in Bach's Well-Tempered Clavier almost exclusively), so the two hands both work about the same, and no finger gives me any particular trouble.
smalin 2 weeks ago
@smalin thanks for the answer,
so did you understand what i meant exactly?
if you look at my Chopin-prelude video you might see particularly, bC_mg30oU1E&list=UUIgzEg-ZLMJv9T9s3ethQvw&index=6&feature=plcp
this is a well-known mistaken posture for the thumb and is there anything to do to gain a new finger posture after being 22?
MrChopiano 2 weeks ago
@MrChopiano I see that your thumb is bent backwards. When you say "I cannot control" the top of your thumb, do you mean that you're physically unable to bend it normally? Or that you have a habit? If it's a habit, you can overcome it.
smalin 2 weeks ago