Simon Keenlyside "Finch'han dal vino" Don Giovanni
Top Comments
All Comments (103)
-
winstons123 is right--this song does not have to go that fast. There's barely any time for this guy's voice to resonate AT ALL. When you're moving that fast, all you can demonstrate is that your voice is agile, but you cannot demonstrate better than average tone. If he has a beautiful voice, you'd never know it from this rendition. Just that he's an athlete... which is NOT all there is.
-
He is superb, but no Siepi
-
@WINSTONS123 Anno 2011 it is......Party Party Party
-
@WINSTONS123 o yes it is...
-
this aria is not a race.
-
A brilliant version, I love it. This is my favourite aria, ever.
-
Quest'uomo è un gioiello: questa secondo me è la esatta interpretazione che bisogna dare al brano! Molto migliore di quelle versioni, vedi Bryn Terfel, che rimbottano ogni frase perdendo la velocità e staccando con delle pause... Non capisco come mai si dedichi tanto ai tragici ruoli verdiani, io lo vedo perfetto in questi ruoli comici rossiniani o mozartiani (come appunto Don Giovanni o il suo indimenticabile Papageno)
-
2 seconds faster than Losonczy on he Klemperer recording - Simon, you ROCK.
-
He is wonderful
-
@ejb61 well he is a geordie and with thomas allan and owen brannigon. so there are 3 famous geordie opera singers and there's also 1 famous rock singer Brian Johnson current front man for AC/DC.
this guy is vital, intense, commited, burning inside, and has a damm fine voice.
ejb61 2 years ago 54
Keenlyside is marvelous. His interpretation, here, sings the fastest version of this aria I have ever heard. Ramey and Furlanetto can't quite keep pace. He is setting the bar high.
Urineculture 2 years ago 31