Fridabad, Bhai Manpreet Singh Kanpuri & Dasam Granth_Part 1

According to Sikh Rehat Maryada, kirtan may only be done of bani of Guru Granth Sahib, writings of Bhai Gurdas & Bhai Nand Lal and Nitnem banis. Bhai Manpreet Singh Kanpuri recited kachi bani in violation of Rehat Maryada instructions and then sought to justify it.

Category:

News & Politics

Tags:

• Manpreet Singh Kanpuri
• Kahnpuri
• Gurbani Kirtan
• kachi bani
• dasam granth
• deras
• babas
• kirtan
• Khalsa
• Rehat Maryada
• SGPC

[harry8068]

I am very confused right now - I love to sing shabads and the shabad "As Kirpan Khand Kharag" is in the Amrit Keertan...should we not sing it then...why is this in the Amrit Keertan?

Please advise.

[SikhCentre]

@harry8068 There is no reason to be confused. Look for the meaning of the whole "As Kirpan Khand Kharag..." and the context in which it occurs. If you think it is in accordance with Gurmat Sidhant enshrined in Guru Granth Sahib, continue to sing it. If you think (as I do) that it violates many basic principles of Gurmat, decide accordingly.

[satnamkaur88]

please go n read the Sikh Rehat Mariyada issued by SGPC only.i dnt think u had ever seen even bus video dekhi te post karn di jaldi theek hai post karo par argue na karo jaa ke pado te dekho whichone is right n wrong

[81harmeet]

BAHUT KHOOB 22 JI

[meripatnayatra]

Kanpuri is a Biggest LIAR abnormal Kid your assesment is veri right jan bhuj ke vivad paida kita.

[prince15480]

I agree, if Bhai Manpreet Singh ji knew that there are people in the sangat who gonna oppose the shabad which he gonna sing then why he sung that shabad at first place. Wat is think is here was the ego issue for BHai ji. My only concern was about the disrespect of Guru Granth Sahib JI and it could have been avoided by not singing this particular shabad and singing other shabad frm Guru Granth Sahib ji. it is very sad.

[SikhCentre]

I took those lines above on Kirtan from SGPC Rehat Maryada printed in 1989. If they are printing in parenthesis that "Gurbani means bani of Guru Granth and Guru Gobind Singh hymns" then you can see that this modification is not even 20 years old.

[SikhCentre]

Veerey, you seem to be trying to take the discussion into "who is worse" area. Does it matter who is violating Maryada more? If you search the net you will find a lot about the Namdharis and where Prof Darshan Singh has commented on them directly or indirectly.

I do not need to contact Manpreet Singh - for I have not contacted Prof Darshan Singh either :-) Prof has always made his stand known - Manpreet Singh should do the same.

[satnamkaur88]

pls concern about the history n thn post the comments because GURU GOBIND SINGH patshah ji ne sirf apne pita GURU TEG BHADUR SAHIB JI di bani add kariyi si je OHNE BANI uchari ohndi te oh jarur add karde kisi pujari ya badal ne ohna nuy rokeya nahi si but he was having a too busy life as he had 14 jungs in the age of 42 he completed his life n in d past time jungs were not of a day or two they go for years n he had 14 jungs with his sikh soldiers n won all by grace of GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI only

[avtar35]

Veer jee how is Sant Samaaj same as Naam Dhariye? Jagjit Singh openly claims to be the 14 th Guru. When did Prof Darshan Singh or for that fact any Singh Sahiban etc have brought Naamdhariye to task?

Have you tried to contact Manpreet Singh to know his stand on these ?

The Rehat Maryada pamphlet I am referring to is 1994 english edition of Sikh Rehat Maryada.Which edition are you referring to?