Bach - Invention No 1 in C major
Uploader Comments (afpaSTU1096)
All Comments (11)
-
Great!:)
-
A very clean and precise performance. Cool ending.
-
Hmmmm....sounds familiar. :-) ...much like the Alfred version's CD. It is that version that I'm trying to "copy" because it's one of the nicer versions I've heard. I read some of the other comments on voicing, appreggios, and whether or not to play the broken chord. I'll have to analyze this again when I know more about this piece. Anyway, this will definitely be another piece that you and I have in common. I am past the 1st page now and ready to begin work on that daunting 2nd page.
-
To top that, this is my favorite Inventions! Like!
-
Wow, i saw this on my personal tag from the video. This is great man! Steady and clear! Haha, Darkboy you're here too?
-
Thanks for the comment! I've been hearing so many people working on the inventions, so I decided to revisit one of the pieces I've learned in the past. Your evenness and clarity of voices in this recording is admirable. And what a lovely cadence at the end! I love the warm sound of your piano, too.
-
and and sorry for bothering you, with 'modern' I mean, you give it a bit a romantic touch , not baroque at all ! thats why it sounds also a bit strange to me ;)
-
when my is uploaded if you don't mind :) ? .. I think it fits more to this piece, to keep it 'small' :)
anyways again, well done .. I know how hord those pieces are for us 'beginners' so well done mr ! many people would fail in practice those pieces :) !
Also after a few more times listing it, the end, the arrpegios why do you do that :) ? just want to know your motivation of it ;) ? in my ears it sounds a bit to 'modern' in this invention ! a bit to much , because if you watch the the holl pieces, there are not many notes played at the same time, thats why the arpgegios at the end sounds a bit to ... much for me, a bit to many notes at once, a bit to 'modern' I would prefer it a bit diffrence, then I will show you an other alternative end
Darkboy2525 5 months ago
@Darkboy2525 - I had been practicing a different ending, which was as written with an mordent on the highest C note. The broken chord ending I think is quite common. Bach scholar does it this way and also on the CD that came with my Alfred's music book. I chose the broken chord on the fly because my hands would sometimes freeze trying to play the mordent. So to save the recording I went with the broken chord because it's easier to play. Playing at home I play as written with mordent :)
afpaSTU1096 5 months ago