Josef Hofmann plays Rubinstein Concerto No. 4 (1/4)
Uploader Comments (truecrypt)
Top Comments
-
Definitely the 1937 recording. The others from the 40s are no good because Hofmann's technique was not in good shape by then. This 1937 one is a total classic, as is just about everything from the Golden Jubilee performance, which features arguably the best Chopin First Ballade and Andante Spinato and Grande Polonaise ever recorded. The Rubinstein 4 is a good concerto, but Hofmann's playing makes it better than it is.
-
And there are and were many people that for some reason or another don't like Hofmann.
(I'm not one of those people...)
Video Responses
All Comments (55)
-
Anton Rubinstein was very popular in Russia and early Soviet Union. Then due to antisemitic tendencies of the later years of Stalinism Rubinstein was almost faded out from public performances.
-
I failed to mention in the post of mine just a few moments ago that the VAI Audio item is a 2-CD set with many other works played by Hofmann including Brahms Chopin, Mendelsssohn, Rachmaninov, Moszkowski, Beethoven,Rachmaninov and two composed by Hofmann.
-
Many years ago in my youth I bought and still have the LP of this piano concerto played admirably by Oscar Levant with the New York Philharmonic under Dimitri Mitropolous. I currently have the VAI Audio CD "The Complete Josef Hofmann- Vol. 2"in which the live performance of this work by Hofmann is contained. I bought it through Amazon.com if any of you are interested in buying it.
-
Rubinstein was such an amazing personality. Most of his concert reviews in all major 19-th century periodicals say the same thing--to hear him play was once in a life time experience. One of his contemporary musicians called Rubinstein a 'murderer of music' because he said that after hearing him play a piece, no one else's interpretation came even close. Rubinstein as a composer was not super amazing, but he played his own music in the way that it made it sound mesmerising.
-
Astounding! TY.
-
@Gargantupimp wow, your 2 for two- I am english and in therapy!
-
@Deneb33 I think if more people played it like this than it would be much more appreciated.
-
@Bruce88keys this is boring to you? Either your from england or you need to get your head examined.
-
I played this concerto as a kid because my teacher played it when he was a kid- I thought it was a total bore, and it is, which is a reason it fell out of the performance repetoire- Its derivative at best, better a young student spend time & work on a Mozart or Beethoven, something conductors would program.
-
@marklavar My god! I was wondering why he seemed so familiar to me!
is it possible to get the score of this concerto? I just don't understand why Anton Rubinstein's music is not played more today!! I heard about this concerto but this is the first time I have ever heard it!!
cdpiano27 2 years ago 2
Yes, it's available @ IMSLP site.
I'm sending you an URL by PM
truecrypt 2 years ago