Odeon by Ernesto Nazareth, Bernd Lhotzky HD
Top Comments
All Comments (38)
-
The scales aren't in the original score and he didin't played the music until the end.
-
The left hand is one octave bellow than the original. His interpretation is good but I feel some swingless. I'm brazilian. Listen to Arthur Moreira Lima.
-
Hmm, not to be negative, but I don't think Mr. Lhotzky quite gets this style. His rendition is a bit too sedate. This is dance music.
-
check out Manuel Barrueco's version (with incredible introduction) from his Nylon & Steel recording. It's so far beyond anyone's version on piano (let alone guitar) you simply will never be satisfied with anyone else's. Incomparable
-
Nazareth himself recorded it and played it slow. This is not a Bach toccata in a Liszt-Busoni arrangement.
-
Oh my... It doesn't matter if he plays slow or fast. There's a poetic license to do this and anyone can play the compositions as wish. The question itself is not if played slow or fast. But because ART can must exhale technique too, but most important that everybody knows. FEELING! Every music style has personality and an own face wich must be considerated while you playing. Why the player doesn't do those things? Maybe he was having a bad day. But he could not transmit Choro's feeling to me.
-
@weedmasterfreak Listen to Arthur Moreira Lima, then you will have the right to say anything about this piece.
-
@weedmasterfreak This was indeed not a "shitty" performance, but if you knew anything about music, you would realize that he puts no feeling into the performance. He hits every note, but he cannot deliver the true feeling this song holds. He hits every note at the right time, but the music overall has no feeling as the composer meant.
-
@yojukitomodele If you know anything about music, you can't say this is a shitty performance, because it most certainly is not. I bet my shiny arse you aren't even close to this good at playing the piano, so you have nothing to say. This was a great performance. Slower than the versions you're used to hear, but still perfectly played.
-
Tango and happy.... That's new...
Because it sounds better
NDNewitt 1 year ago 12
Seems stiff to me. The guy is obviously very good, and it is better than many videos in wich people try to play it. But one thing is getting clear to me: not everybody can deliver this one... Don't like it
Carimbo575 5 months ago 5