Carl/Ellie - Goodbye to You
Uploader Comments (BeaverAru)
Top Comments
-
The DVD footage looks Russian, but what Ellie writes at the end was; 'Thank you for the adventure, now have a new adventure of your own'
All the years as a child I was dragged to Disney Movies in a half-nelson, I hated every f*cking minute of it. Now as a 37 year old man, they produce an animation that blows me away. Fantastic Movie- Carl is my hero!!!
All Comments (92)
-
it's good...
i really like it...
:')
-
It`s different, but in a way it`s great.
You did a great job on this one.
2 hours of hard work, makes a nice vid.
And, i want to thank you for that.
UP is now one of my favorit movies of all time.
Again, thanks.
-
I love this movie.... The song from the video is Michelle Branch - "Goodbye To You"
-
Who sings this song? This voice reminds me of Michelle Branch.
-
are you trying to make fun of up
-
i cry because the video and musci
-
@charmander4533 LMFAO LOL
-
the music is ok jerks



"At the heart of the story of Up is the tragic, yet beautiful love relationship between Carl and Ellie"
Their love is anything but tragic - just beautiful, the sort of romance many people often dream of having. It's sad when Ellie dies, but no tragedy - just life, and that's why it's sad. The fact that they couldn't have kids makes it worse as poor Carl is left a lonely old man :'(
Btw, this song doesn't "embody the feeling of Carl's loss", it just makes it needlessly corny and seem superficial.
wimilicous101 10 months ago 8
@wimilicous101 I'm always VERY happy to see people so passionate about this movie that they call me on my song choice, saying the film is better and deserves more. Because that shows me this film really touched them, like it did me. And I admit, the song choice wasn't the best. At the time it was a song I loved, and I found connections to the movie in it's lyrics. And I agree, the movie is very much about life. Both the good and bad.
Thanks for the very insightful comment!
BeaverAru 10 months ago 3
good thing this shitty music was playing or else I would have been sad watching this
charmander4533 1 year ago 19
@charmander4533 Ah, well, not for everyone I suppose. We all have different tastes.
BeaverAru 1 year ago
Please don't ruin such a great movie with your crappy music
TheDarkNobleOne 1 year ago
@TheDarkNobleOne I'm glad to hear you're an Up fan, but my apologies our musical tastes don't line up.
BeaverAru 1 year ago 4