Quran contradiction on Abraham, Ishmael, Isaac & Jacob

1) Notes written in Mecca:
Quran 6:84 (P) -- Mecca
And We bestowed upon him (Abraham), Isaac and Jacob; each of them We guided; and Noah did We guide aforetime; and of his seed: David and Solomon and Job and Joseph and Moses and Aaron. ...


Quran 19:49 (P) -- Mecca
"... We gave him (Abraham), Isaac and Jacob. Each of them We made a prophet."
As Jacob was the grandson of Abraham, it shows the lineage of prophets as both of them are not the sons bestowed to Abraham.


Quran 21:72 (P) -- Mecca
And We bestowed upon him (Abraham) Isaac, and Jacob as a grandson. Each of them We made righteous.
Quran 12:38 (P) -- Mecca
And I have followed the religion of my fathers, Abraham and Isaac and Jacob. ...


Quran 29:27 (P) -- Mecca
"And We bestowed on him, Isaac and Jacob, and we established the Prophethood and the Scripture among his seed..."
As "his seed" is Abraham's seed in this context: Abraham and his seed: Isaac & Jacob. Ishmael was excluded as his seed!


Quran 38:45 (P) -- Mecca
"And make mention of Our bondmen, Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, men of parts and vision."
Ishmael is not mentioned as the servant of God right after Abraham but instead to his seed: Isaac and Jacob.




2) Notes written in Madina.


3 verses corrupted with Ishmael inserted while in Madina but absent in Mecca!!!

1. Quran 4:163 -- Madina
Lo! We inspire thee as We inspired Noah and the prophets after him, as We inspired Abraham and ISHMAEL and Isaac and Jacob and the tribes, and Jesus and Job and Jonah and Aaron and Solomon, and as We imparted unto David the Psalms

2. Quran 3:84 -- Madina
Say : We believe in Allah and that which is revealed unto us and that which was revealed unto Abraham and ISHMAEL and Isaac and Jacob and the tribes, and that which was vouchsafed unto Moses and Jesus and the prophets from their Lord. We make no distinction between any of them, and unto Him we have surrendered.

3. Quran 2:136 -- Madina
Say : We believe in Allah and that which is revealed unto us and that which was revealed unto Abraham, and ISHMAEL, and Isaac, and Jacob, and the tribes, and that which Moses and Jesus received, and that which the prophets received from their Lord. We make no distinction between any of them, and unto Him we have surrendered.


Six Quranic notes (6:84, 12:38, 19:49, 21:72, 29:27 & 38:45) purportedly written in Mecca which CONTRADICT with 3 Quranic notes 4:163, 3:84 & 2:136 written at Madina. The lying pen of the Scribe or false witness has falsely inserted ISHMAEL between ABRAHAM and ISAAC for the notes written in Madina.

Category:

Education

Tags:

• Quran contradiction on Abraham
• Ishmael
• Isaac & Jacob

[m3d2]

really precious what you did if it was correct,and that add more authenticity and the fact that the Quran was indeed from God , or why mohmmed in the madina that was fraught by the jews insist about Ishmael and his covenant, if it was man mad he will at least avoid this issue to gaining the jews,thank you for that.

BTW where is the contradiction ? contradiction mean opposition between two conflicting forces or ideas so when i say 1,2,3 then i said 1,3 that not contradiction so try again ...

[positron66]

@m3d2 By the Admission of MUHAMMAD, he declared "We BELIEVE in that which hath been revealed unto US and revealed unto YOU". Surah 29:46

GOSPEL - JOHN 10:30 Yehoshua said "I and my Father are ONE."

As MUHAMMAD believed and surrendered to YEHOSHUA as ONE ALLAH, then Muslims are all LIARS for failing to follow the ACTS of the RAPIST of 9-year old Virgin Aisha.

Can a RAPIST be worthy to bring guidance to mankind?

[atwilliams8]

Also, Davis speaks praises to the people that walk to the Valley of Beka, which i was told was another name for Mecca. This is in Psalm 84, which is dedicated to the worthy brothers of the Korah!!! The greatest evidence, however, for Islam is Genesis 33 given by Moses before his death. He says when God comes he will be with the holy people. It says God "cane from Sinai and dawned over them from Seir, he shown forth from Mount Paran" Sinai is Moses/Jews, Seir/Jerusalem Jesus and Christians,

[positron66]

@atwilliams8 By the Admission of MUHAMMAD, he declared "We BELIEVE in that which hath been revealed unto US and revealed unto YOU". Surah 29:46

GOSPEL - JOHN 10:30 Yehoshua said "I and my Father are ONE."

As MUHAMMAD believed and surrendered to YEHOSHUA as ONE ALLAH, then Muslims are all LIARS for failing to follow the ACTS of the RAPIST of 9-year old Virgin Aisha.

Can a RAPIST be worthy to bring guidance to mankind? Sex with girl below 16 years age of consent is termed as rape

[EUguitarRULE]

Keep the good fight you are a warrior of the most High! You have opened my eys about Islam.

[chezpiecedaking]

@soloscriptura1 The comforter is Muhammad,The spirit of truth.

[OneReligionIslam]

This in not a contradiction brother. God made Isaac and Jacob prominent in their linage and mentioned them as ancestors...in other verses He mentioned Ismail too ...and was a messenger too.[19:54] And mention in the scripture Ismail. He was truthful when he made a promise, and he was a messenger prophet..It deosn't matter if he was born of a slave woman according to Bible.

[asimriaz78]

There are not a single contradiction in Islam: May you go to Hell

[xArabianxBeastx]

@positron66 Wrong. read Sura 29:49 "Rather, the Qur'an is distinct verses [preserved] within the breasts of those who have been given knowledge. And none reject Our verses except the wrongdoers." You're so repetitive. You've said that verse in every comment I've seen xD. You're truly dumb TROLOLOL

[MrEljasmi]

this video is valid to me as a muslim when it comes that hajer and our father ismael were left in mecca and ishmael was a child then..

and its trure that sarah had her baby isac not long after ishmael cause of of the story of hajer searching for water for her baby in mecca, so if ishmael was old enough then he could help hajer to search

and yes ebraham--isac-- jacob-- 12 sons-- tribe of israel.the right sequence and fom these triibes came most of our prophets.

ibraham--ishmel------ mohammed

[m3d2]

@m3d2

before 14 Centuries marriage of 9year old was widely practiced among Arabs back then even in US girls at the age of 10 were also being married just more than a century ago and their parents the one how offered her to the prophet to marry her not one Or twice but three time before he proposed to her so what is u r point or did ur arrogance make u think that ur western pagan standard is matter to any nation ?!!!?

[m3d2]

@positron66

will in the Quran is talk alot about the corrupt of u r books and we believe that Allah revealed to them but we don't believe in what inside it coz they distort their books.

[m3d2]

@positron66

they are One so what is your point

[positron66]

@bibleresponse By the Admission of MUHAMMAD, he declared "We BELIEVE in that which hath been revealed unto US and revealed unto YOU". Surah 29:46

GOSPEL - JOHN 10:30 Yehoshua said "I and my Father are ONE."

As MUHAMMAD believed and surrendered to YEHOSHUA as ONE ALLAH, then Muslims are all LIARS for failing to follow the ACTS of the RAPIST of 9-year old Virgin Aisha.

Can a RAPIST be worthy to bring guidance to mankind?