Top Comments
Video Responses
All Comments (664)
-
@TheConsumerman Eva Cassidy does indeed do this song well, plaintive and poignant. I really feel as though I want to listen to it. I'm feeling quite sad today.
-
@Sharsie I like Eva Cassidy's version. Strangely enough, the ethereal quality of her interpretation reminds me of some of the mellifluous, soft voiced French singers of the sixties.
Really, I didn't intend to start a war between rival camps. I can appreciate the different qualities of all the best versions, of which Eva Cassidy's is one. My point is simply that French chanson is text based; the lyric is declaimed and hence it sounds more poetic than when sung in the English style.
-
@vja65 I have indeed. I like to hear the many different versions of this song and I like artists who can can reveal the melancholy of the lyric and the melody in their own way. Eva Cassiday's version is ethereal, soft and spectral and I like it. I'm not going to draw up a league table and start ranking all the versions in order, mind. Where would you place Chet Baker, Miles Davis, Sinatra... ? I used to have a 90 min tape with all my favourite versions on - Eva Cassidy is on there.
-
@vja65 granted it is not of the same generation...different troubles and travails :)
-
@hardyfh1 and you have heard eva cassidy's version?
-
@hardyfh1 Eva Cassidy really does this song well. This version is very good too.
-
@Sharsie It was Eva Cassidy that brought me here... I always get goose bumps when I hear Eva singing it!!! Haven't tired of listening to it in the past 10 years.
-
@eatablealan You are so right, WHO can bring a soul into the concrete world these days?
-
yeah, sounds far better in french
-
what a voice...i cant even....wao ♥
I try to make it a policy not to join in the endless, pointless debates as to which song or singer is better than another, but I do have to say that on this, my all time favourite song, the French versions by Greco, Montand and Piaf are in a class of their own. The lyrical approach of chanson brings out the true depth and meaning of this song, whereas English speaking versions - many brilliantly sung - gloss over the loss and melancholy. The French singers have the poetry and gravitas.
hardyfh1 4 months ago 44
This grand lady's songs will always be a class act,
44mkb 2 months ago 8