Piano Cover-Romance- Jean Sibelius, op. 24, no.9
Uploader Comments (manduhhc)
All Comments (22)
-
bitches, yall should stop criticizing her with ur judgement. its good, sounds good, stop with the criticism like u know better
-
@manduhhc while i heartgossipgurl is pretty rude and tactless, they have a point - listening to others to get some rhythms right isn't a bad idea. And I think you need to work on tempo and volume dynamics. Using the same through each section sounds robotic. Give the song some soul. Put yourself in the composer's position, use some past experiences, and put it all into the performance.
On the other hand I actually like the song slower. A lot of performances on youtube rush through it too much.
-
good performance overall but watch the dynamics more in the piano range. other than that it sounded beautiful
-
You need practice but nice try!:)
-
yeah im learning this right now, and great job i really like it... (that i heart gossip fag is a dick and really doesn't know what he is talking about btw)
-
lol Jean is my teacher too >.>
-
also even though this doesn't apply to me because i play piano, Simen Cowell doesn't sing and yet he can recognise genius singers and from the very start can pick out crappy ones. So your logic doesn't really work. Actually generalizing, logic is a part of math and math a part of music... I don't really need to explain further.
-
i wasn't spelling right so i could fit in all my comments. theres a word count so i took out some letters. And actually I'm playing Romance right now, If your still interested in february, i'll be posting a video then. Ill make sure to send you a message. And obviously you know it was a crappy performance or you wouldn't have sidetracked and talked about spelling or trying to put it on me. Adn seriously if you haven't already, listen to the other videos:|:|:|:|.



I hope you dont take it the wrong way if i offer some contructive criticism? There are a few things that you should do to take this to the next level! There are certain parts of this piece that should be faster. The octave section should get progressively faster and end very fast. Also the D scale could be a little faster. Also, you could memorize this piece. The lady takes away from the performance.
It was a spectacular performance take it to the next level!
ScheideProductions 2 years ago
thank you!
manduhhc 2 years ago
"iheartgossipgurl" is a douche =P
Don't listen to him, good job!
TheDeLi 3 years ago
Thank you! I appreciate it! =]
manduhhc 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is proably the worst version of this song i've ever heard. i suggest you listen to other normal people play this song, there are others on youtube and then compare yours.its not performace ready, you have a really bad tone on piano and you completely missed the point of the song. i could't get through the first 2 seconds without thinking wow this person can't play piano.The poeple tht commented on this you probably know,thats why their giving you compliments. They don't play piano do they?
iheartgossipgurl 3 years ago
While I play piano, maybe you should take spelling lessons. Please refer me to your video of the 'Romance'. Oh right, you don't have one.
manduhhc 3 years ago