"Something cannot come from nothing" - The Atheist Experience #675
Loading...
Uploaded by TheAtheistExperience on Sep 21, 2010
Troy (a.k.a. Youtube user Parture) from Edmonton, Alberta (Canada) tries to prove the existence of God with the argument that "something cannot come from nothing," as popularized by Christian apologists like William Lane Craig. This call is a follow-up to an e-mail discussion that can be read on the Atheist Experience Blog and Biblocality.com.
This is an edited clip from The Atheist Experience #675 of September 19, 2010 (topic: viewer calls) with Russell Glasser and Martin Wagner. The complete show can be watched on Blip.tv and Ustream.tv:
► http://blip.tv/file/4143603
► http://www.ustream.tv/recorded/9691385
RELATED LINKS:
► Axp Blog: http://atheistexperience.blogspot.com/2010/09/open-thread-on-show-675.html
► Biblocality: http://biblocality.com/forums/showthread.php?3814-How-I-Personally-Know-Unequ...
► Parture: http://www.youtube.com/user/Parture
Lecture: 'A Universe From Nothing' by Lawrence Krauss, AAI 2009
► http://www.youtube.com//watch?v=7ImvlS8PLIo
NOTE:
TheAtheistExperience is a fan appreciatian channel on YouTube. The operator of this channel does not speak on behalf of the ACA or any other atheist. The "debate" between Troy (Parture) and the operator of this channel on Biblocality.com was just a quick response to a message that was sent to this channel. Troy never pointed out that he would publish the reply on his own blog and carry on the "debate" there. When asked to removed it, he simply said, "No." Oh well...
WHAT IS THE ATHEIST EXPERIENCE?
The Atheist Experience is a weekly cable access television show in Austin, Texas, geared at a non-atheist audience. It is produced by the Atheist Community of Austin. The Atheist Community of Austin is organized as a nonprofit educational corporation to develop and support the atheist community, to provide opportunities for socializing and friendship, to promote secular viewpoints, to encourage positive atheist culture, to defend the first amendment principle of state-church separation, to oppose discrimination against atheists and to work with other organizations in pursuit of common goals.
VISIT THE ACA'S OFFICIAL WEB SITES:
► Community: http://www.atheist-community.org
► TV Show: http://www.atheist-experience.com
► Axp Blog: http://atheistexperience.blogspot.com
► E-mail: tv@atheist.community.org (with AETV in the subject line)
- 1,282 likes, 46 dislikes
-
View attributions »
Link to this comment:
Top Comments
Video Responses
All Comments (3,043)
-
The universe did not come from NOTHING! The Big Bang was an EXPANSION of everything, not a 'creation from nothing'.
If this blockheaded caller could understand that the expansion was matter, energy, and space, he'd get why the hosts are refuting him.
-
I'm getting tired of people like this caller. They're so fucking stupid and ignorant!
-
When Christians tell me something can't come from nothing I just say well your saying god came from nothing
-
@6:59 "You're just doling out the fallacies like a vending machine."
Great analogy.
-
@xBlackEditionx what a perfect way to explain it with logical science i am stealing this lol
-
Proof of Something coming from nothing:
No evidence for cause of big bang:
=
Big bang was created by Yahweh!!!!
-
Wait, did he just say "that's right"? What a foolish person.
-
@taylan637 I believe carl sagan addressed this, quite eloquently I might add.
-
This caller is so dense..."If science cant provide the answer then the god of the bible is true". Thats his argument? Really??? LOL!
- 8:53
"Reasons for accepting atheism" - The Atheist Experience #668by TheAtheistExperience60,910 views
- 5:43
"Richard Dawkins Calls" The Atheist Experienceby BrainInSkull62,741 views
- 8:36
Apostasy, death threats, and fear of hell - The Atheist Experience #656by TheAtheistExperience36,425 views
- 8:33
"Christians don't understand the character of God" - The Atheist Experience #668by TheAtheistExperience84,940 views
- 8:32
God is for idiotsby FluffyAthiest112,346 views
- 4:31
What is holding up the Earth? - The Atheist Experience #667by TheAtheistExperience63,940 views
- Atheist Experience FAN CHANNELchannel276 videos
- 12:01
"Are atheists fools?" (and more) - The Atheist Experience #669by TheAtheistExperience49,692 views
- 4:31
How do you know God isn't real? - The Atheist Experience #654by TheAtheistExperience124,548 views
- 12:12
"I have two scientific reasons why I am not an atheist" - Atheist Experience show #737by eminescinescu51,411 views
- 9:47
Matt's Brilliant Response - The Atheist Experience 696by chadwick009144,939 views
- 11:00
"No afterlife is unacceptable to me!" - The Atheist Experience #656by TheAtheistExperience79,037 views
- 8:53
Creaming data to promote religion - The Atheist Experience #659by TheAtheistExperience18,798 views
- 11:19
"Polonium halos prove..." - The Atheist Experience #661 (clip 1/3)by TheAtheistExperience44,445 views
- 8:56
Dawkins lays the smack down on the Popeby Thunderf00t137,210 views
- 7:35
2 + 2 = 4, Therefore God - The Atheist Experience 441by village1diot37,396 views
- 9:35
Thoughtless Arguments - The Atheist Experience #693by TheMidwestAtheist12,070 views
- 7:00
When were the gospels written? - The Atheist Experience #656by TheAtheistExperience30,590 views
- 14:56
What kind of evidence would prove God? - The Atheist Experience #638by TheAtheistExperience51,832 views
- 14:51
Where to begin? - The Atheist Experience #666by TheAtheistExperience59,036 views
- 6:31
"Atheists are immoral!" - The Atheist Experience #680by TheAtheistExperience48,511 views
I like how the guy on the phone is getting super pissed off while everyone is laughing at him. xD
DJ100101 1 month ago 21
Everybody that's reading this, Think about this, If something cannot come from nothing. That means there was never the term "nothing" to begin with. That means there is no such thing as "nothing" which in science is true because if you take away all radiation and particles you get dark matter. Dark matter has always been there and quantum fluctuations from it caused the big bang producing a universe.
xBlackEditionx 1 month ago 12