The Magic Flute - Queen of the Night aria
Top Comments
All Comments (242)
-
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaamaz
ing
-
@hughdrover Although the assumption makes a lot of sense out of the plot, Sarastro is NEVER mentioned to be Pamina's father. I studied this opera in one of my University courses, and in one of my essays I suggested that Pamila was Sarastro's daughter. My professor wasn't impressed: she wrote on my essay "If this were the case, don't you think Mozart wasted the opportunity for a dramatic moment of revelation"?
-
@jonnybabes84 From The Oxford Dictionary of Opera, a reliable enough source: “Singspiel - Song-play, a term for a German drama in which musical numbers are separated by dialogue... such works were written in the 17th century. The influence of French opéra-comique and English ballad opera (18th century) helped to develop Singspiel as a genre of comic opera with spoken dialogue."
-
@hughdrover wiki is an unreliable source. a singspiel has always been classified as a "comic opera" which was the most popular type of opera in the classical period (1750-1825).
-
@hughdrover I admit that I was wrong to use the word 'always', but Grove's Dictionary of Music and Musicians describes a singspiel as "an opera, usually comic and in German with spoken dialogue." Grove's is a far more creditable resource than Wikipedia.
-
What's In A Name' It's Just Wonderful Entertainment'''' Enjoy
-
In any case, she does a fantastic job and in the right octave although a little slower pace than Diana Damrau. It's interesting to hear it in English.
-
@briannadominique13 It's an operetta.
-
i think it's nice to hear opera in your native tongue occasionally.
-
@zingzangspillip1 what began as music has now become a pedantic quibble of etymology. You appear to be the wrong one by saying "a singspiel has always been classified as a type of opera" . Read what Wiki says, starting with "Some of the first Singspiele were miracle plays in Germany". I think we should now lay the nit-picking to rest. No further gain for anyone - least of all Mozart.
@briannadominique13 You say of yourself “I'm blonde, talkitive [sic], and Canadian. That's all you really need to know”. Perhaps you should consider adding ‘dogmatic, opinionated and illogical'. By your definition. Die Fledermaus, Carmen, Tales of Hoffmann etc. would not be operas because they have dialogue, whereas the 'through sung' musicals of Lloyd Webber would be operas.
Doesn't quite work like that. The Magic Flute has a German text so that the Austrian audience would understand it.
hughdrover 1 year ago 26
What's with that ridiculous costume? she looks like she's wandered in from some Elizabethan play!! Actually she sings this very well... but it sounds a lot scarier in German...
DazFromOz 2 years ago 18