American Idol top 5 Performances all time

5)Lakisha Jones-And I'm Telling You-Season 6 top 12 Girls
4)Fantasia Barrino-Summertime-Season 3 Top 8
3)Haley Reinhart-House of The Rising Sun-Season 10 Top 5
2)Jordin Sparks-I Who Have Nothing-Season 6 Top 3
1)Pia Toscano-I'll Stand By You-Season 10 Top 12 Girls

I do not own the content in this video.

Category:

Music

Tags:

• American
• Idol
• Best
• Performances

[jacomani89]

BUT THE ORIGINAL DIVAS OF AI WASNT INCLUDED MS KELLY CLARKSON AND TAMYRA GRAY WERE NOT INCLUDED AND MIND YOU THEY WERE ROCKIN IT BEFORE AMERICAN IDOL DIDNT HAVE THE FUNDS TO HAVE HIGH PRODUCTION VALUE COMPLETE WITH SMOKEY MIRRORS AND FLAMES TO HIDE BEHIND I THINK AMERICA SHOULD START JUDGIN FOR TALENT AGAIN OVER GIMICKS PLEASE!!

[xramborinox]

@jacomani89 Kelly Clarkson is and always will be my favorite winner and contestant on the show. With That said her best performances were I will Survive, It's Raining Men and Respect none of which are good enough to be considered top 5. Plus she's gotten alot better since leaving the show hense her career being so good. She's #1 on best contestants ever. Tamyra Gray's A House is Not a Home damn near made this list. But I thought these 5 were slightly stronger. Just an Opinion.

[TatianaLerman90434]

Glad you have Haley in there, but kind of weird that you have Jordan's "I who have nothing" over Haley's. In my opinion, Haley's was better and with more emotion... to each his own, I guess.

[xramborinox]

@TatianaLerman90434 adam lambert was more consistant than blow me away, (if you look on my worst 5 ever his ring of fire is on there it was TERRIBLE) Haleys I who have nothing didint have more emotion than Jordin Sparks but it was still damn good.

[estebansasuke20]

The version of Haley is better than the Jordin of i who .......I respect your desicion , thanks for incluide Haley and Pia , that are amazing singers

[xramborinox]

@estebansasuke20 I think Jordan had more emotion in her song, Haleys probably would have been about #8 had i done a top 10, if i did a top ten it would be 6)Hallejuah-Jason Castro 7)Tamyra Gray-A House Is Not a Home

8)Haley Reinhart-I Who Have Nothing 9)Carrie Underwood-Alone 10)Clay Aiken-Bridge Over Troubled Water.

[SIRET99]

where is Adam Lambert?!?

[sasuke14191]

@jeremysstarr lol american idol is sexism for the guys xD

[moorephotos]

These are all worthy of consideration, but you should title this your favorite 5 performances of all time. Neither You (nor I) are capable of declaring the best five. Cannot overlook performances by Kelly, Tamara, Clay, Carrie, Adam, or especially Katharine performing "Somewhere Over The Rainbow". (If you are interested, I have video from 2011 tour on my channel)

[jeremysstarr]

sexism- straight up

[jacomani89]

Personally Pia is a little over rated to me.. perfect example of a beautifully trained voice with a face to match with absolute 0 stage presence and lacks true emotion behind, do i think she can sing a baled really well yes, anything else she falls through!! However completely agree with haylie being in there and thanks for adding fantasia cause she is great!!!!

[Ed911Flint]

The audio for this video is bad, bad, bad!

[ilovemusic6565]

Wheres Lauren ??

[TheFalsified]

What is up with the sound quality? Ugh. And no Adam Lambert or David Cook? This is a biased list...