THE MECHANISM: How Homeopathy Works
Loading...
Link to this comment:
Uploader Comments (Bandershot)
All Comments (346)
-
@BaggyWalker Note the escape hatch of "well constructed," without naming the criteria of what "well constructed" means. I often wonder what would happen if we turned your same vituperative "standards" on the testing of patent pharmacetuicals? LOL!
-
@hjf3022 4 a moment then lets apply YOUR rigor to YOUR assertions. Which meta analysis states "homeopathy performs no better than a placebo under controlled conditions" ? Shang? Shang blows up in the face of anyone who touches it; but at least Shang put his name on his stupidity, which you'll never do. And notice too your statement has the qualifier of "controlled conditions." What controls & by whom are you spewing about? James the hi skool dropout w/$1M to lose Randi? Is that your "science?"
-
@DrSpooglemon IT HAS BEEN DEMONSTRATED, repeatedly, ad nauseam, BIOCHEMICALLY, producing the same specific or similar effects in millions of people 4 over 2 centuries! You accuse us of being illogical, then you go off the rails telling lies & making assumptions, accusations that are prima facie illogical. How do you know what YOU know? There's not 1 study, test or trial that shows what opponents of h-pathy claim. Show me! The argument against it always ends up destroying itself.
-
@CapoeiraPiper You make some good, if not rare observations, a reprieve from the relentless name calling this subject invokes. Fact is that what you are calling for has been done. Run "homeopathy" on PUBMED & you'll find 100's of studies, experiments, 2Xblind tests & trials on the subject, a long history of 1st testing electrochemicals on volunteers to see what their reaction to them is. The prob. now is for those who have been vituperative 2 put down the guns & take a 2nd look.
-
What is the point of positing a mechanism for a phenomenon that has not been demonstrated?
-
This seems like stuff only a handful of people in the world can even begin to understand. It seems to have not have been tested yet to the extent that it should. It seems groundbreaking, while it has been used for ceturies. Above everything else, at this point and time in history it seems unbeliaveble. Procure studies that can build consensus among a community of experts before you publicise something ridiculously unbelievable to common people.
3:04Ben Goldacre on Homeopathyby sciencedotTV47,976 views
Featured Video- 6:55Ben Goldacre on Detoxby frankcswain18,386 views
- 0:15Homeopathic Medicine (Futurama)by vociferous2000321,637 views
- 8:12Homeopathy with Dr. Wernerby XanSimpson217,603 views
- 6:43International Homeopathy Debateby cthomeopathy5,615 views
- 4:47Uri Geller's Daughter Natalie Geller - The Succ...by eyal53112,799 views
- 7:47Homeopathy 3 Emergency Remediesby WebMotionStudioTV6,183 views
- 3:05Naturopathy vs. Homeopathyby iHealthTube8,226 views
- 7:39HOMEOPATHIC ER.by lowlarun17,470 views
- 4:11London 10:23 Homeopathy Overdoseby Psythor19,282 views
- 8:54HOMEOPATHY STOPS CANCER!by Bandershot10,997 views
- 3:29Anti Homeopathy Demonstration Backfiresby Bandershot2,406 views
- 2:44Homeopathy - How Homeopathy Works by Anne Schaddeby HomeopathyHomeStudy5,871 views
- 6:14FLAMING HYPOCRITES and the lies they tellby Bandershot6,751 views
- 10:37James Randi Lecture @ Caltech - Homeopathyby JamesRandiFoundation41,741 views
- 3:36Zicam disproves homeopathyby ZJemptv18,431 views
- 6:55If homeopathy works ... I'll drink my own pissby crispianjago28,137 views
- 10:01Olavius2 Proves Homeopathy to James Randiby Bandershot17,792 views
- 2:44James Randi on YouTube, Skepticism, and John Be...by sleepcity1,216 views
- 14:35James Randi explains homeopathyby RationalResponse621,716 views
Homeopathy excels at treating 1 condition. That condition is dehydration. If you have the names of any papers that are in a generally accepted peer reviewed journal, I would be THRILLED to see it.
No shady journals or authors please.
wowsdrawkcab 4 months ago
@wowsdrawkcab "Homeopathic vs Conventional Treatment of Vertigo A Randomized Double-blind Controlled Clinical Study" Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 1998;124:879-885 (AMA journal)
Now let me ask you a Q or 2. If you think the truth is still on YOUR side, then why not ask if there're any tests that show the biochemical invitro action for high dilutes? Isn't that what the real question is?
&if you're the prop&prof of science,reason&logic, then why request in jest&contempt? $?
Be nice or begone.
Bandershot 4 months ago
@wowsdrawkcab "Homeopathic vs Conventional Treatment of Vertigo A Randomized Double-blind Controlled Clinical Study" Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 1998;124:879-885 (AMA journal)
Now let me ask you a Q or 2. If you think the truth is still on YOUR side, then why not ask if there're any tests that show the biochemical invitro action for high dilutes? Isn't that what the real question is?
&if you're the prop&prof of science,reason&logic, then why request in jest&contempt? $?
Be nice or begone.
Bandershot 4 months ago
Why does homeopathy fail under EVERY empirical test?
Why does EVERY conclusion by every scientific body of many nations say it does no better than placebo?
Shawnruss 11 months ago
@Shawnruss "Every empirical test?" What are you babbling about now? I can quote numerous phys., biochem. & biological tests, trials & studies that show the action of homeopathic remedies. The basophil degranulation test has been replicated now over 2 dozen times! There has yet to be a major metanalysis that has conclusively stated it is a placebo, not even Shang, so if this is not a desperate attempt to save face, why is placebo the putative belief among your imaginary scientists?
Bandershot 7 months ago