TSP's History Of Asia | 亞洲的歷史 | 아시아의 역사 | アジアの歴史

What could have been. 什麼可能是。일 수 있던 무엇이. あったかもしれない何が。Что смогло быть.

Category:

Education

Tags:

• TSP
• TheShadowParliament
• History
• Of
• Asia
• 亞洲的歷史
• 아시아의
• 역사
• アジアの歴史
• История
• Азия

[ThoroughlyConqueredW]

Why in these alternate histories do people always take Inner Mongolia, Tibet, and Xinjiang away from China? The population of Inner Mongolia is 80% Chinese, and Xinjiang 40%; it's just not realistic. The only one of those that was ever unified and self-governing was Tibet.

To be honest, it looks like you mostly rolled the clock back on Russia to Muscovy, China to Qing before the unfair treaties, and Japan to its ideal empire. But I enjoyed indulging in a history of an unemasculated East Asia.

[TheShadowParliament]

@ThoroughlyConqueredW These regions were not always so "Han Chinese" as they are now. When the Qing Dynasty collapsed,many regions broke away in independence. What I thought is that these regions would actually be "independent" for a time,before China would take those regions back. A "de facto" annexation.

My sources for Russia are credible,as to what the Russian Revolution could have been..European Russia from Siberia,as well as the Partition of India not happening,for better circumstances.

[liebstandarteadolf]

@bctvanw They could, if they had the military power. Current borders are largely fixed by kings and their conquests. Those without an imperialistic past have long faded away in histroy.

[bctvanw]

@Phead128

Mongolian Empire.

[Phead128]

@bctvanw

Yes, but the ROC is the successor state to the Qing dynasty... so it can accept Taiwan on behalf of the defunct Qing as successor state under the "Succession of States" international relations theory.

[bctvanw]

@Phead128

Taiwan was part of Japan, when ROC founded.

[Phead128]

@bctvanw

That is not how the "Succession of State" theory works... It's legal by international relations theory for China to claim Taiwan because PRC/ROC claim herself successor state status to the Qing territories. Have you ever taken a course on geopoltiics or international theory?

[merdekaataumati1949]

It is terrible translation.

It does not make a sense.

This must be translated by PC.

[franklu7]

平壤万岁，祖国统一万岁。南韩高丽棒子单挑绝对不是朝鲜人民军的­对手。是男人就单挑。

[intricate4]

Korean was a slave country of China and Japan in history

[bctvanw]

@ThoroughlyConqueredW

Dutch, Spanish, and Japanese had settlements in Taiwan before, so they could come back to take Taiwan back anytime? Use simple logic to think about history instead of "Middle Kingdom" way.