Re: Which is the True Prophetic Line: Ishmael or Isaac?

Ishmile or Issac the only begotton son of Abraham. comments to Jay's video

Category:

People & Blogs

Tags:

• Islam
• Muslim
• Jay
• Smith
• Allah
• Mohamed
• Christianity
• religion
• debate
• Bible
• Koran
• Qu'ran
• Jesus
• Yahweh
• Ishmael
• Isaac

[chadpratch]

So what? Isaac or Ishmael? I'm guessing this is a semantical argument pertaining to the fact that Jesus is link to the second son and Mohammed peace be upon him (don't kill me) is from the fist son therefore the top line. I'm just making a wild guess here but wtf is the big deal. Isaac or Ishmael? why even argue about this? You guys are to funny. I guess cuz Im a agnostic I must be from Cain's line lol.

[naliakbar]

i was responding to the video sent to me, both men are great men in islam, they both are prophets of god and to both of them were promises made.

i am glad taht you atleast believe in god, that is the first step to islam good luck in your search.

[chadpratch]

I guessing you don't know what an agnostic is. You need to look that term up. The Cain's line was a joke. Probably not that funny for you but I get a kick out of it. You didn't really answer the question though. So what? Isaac or Ishmael? Why does a name matter so much to you and to a Jew and a Christian. Can you all get along?

[naliakbar]

I got the joke, importants is that by the claim the jews and christians make they attempt to exclude Ishmile and his children as potentially having a messenger come from them. and that is why it is important to discuss because Muhammad(saw) came from this line. that is why. As for getting along, i believe we can, as the quran teaches if people were to come to common ground there would be understanding, but both sides refuse to, im tired of christians knocking on my door, im knocking back

[The3in1trinity]

@ave383 What r these contradictions u mention is God's Inspired Word the Bible? I doubt u have ever read the Bible, but if u have it wasn't in depth + u lack understanding.Most likely u have watched a video + this becomes ur "evidence"...1 SAVIOUR WHO IS JESUS CHRIST THE SON OF GOD WHO IS GOD IN THE FLESH...Ask God 2 give u understanding of who He is + y He sent His Son Jesus 2 die 4 our sakes...SEEK + YE WILL FIND...

[The3in1trinity]

@naliakbar God's Inspired Word the Bible makes the claim. Jewish ppl+Christians merely believe what God's Word states. God states it plainly. He even states y the Covenant would b with Isaac. Arguing with God's Word will get u nowhere. We don't need 2 ATTEMPT 2 exclude Ishmael. GOD EXCLUDES ISHMAEL! If u r tired it's because u refuse 2 believe God's Word. U prefer 2 believe a man-made koran that God's Word DPESN'T SUPPORT in any way. 1 SAVIOUR WHO IS JESUS CHRIST THE SON OF GOD+GOD IN THE FLESH!

[ghazaail]

haha i laugh at the jew who they lie they deny jesus in his time now they talk in name chrstin and deny ishmeal and know say yes ishmeal was the one who was about to be killed but know the jew again back to make another lies and says issac the one who was to be killed

so their lies never end

they just want all poeple jew

but everyday we find new lies for the jew about god

but alhmdullah we muslim

and they cant change the quran

peace

[The3in1trinity]

A simple reading of the Scripture will show what God says in regards 2the promise made 2Isaac. It doesn't matter what ppl think should have happened GOD WAS THE ONE WHO MADE THE CHOICE 4HIS OWN REASONS. iF U BOTHERED 2READ WHAT GOD SAID THEN U WOULDN'T B SO CONFUSED AS U CLAIM 2B

GENESIS 16:4-16. GENESIS 17:1-22

R u so arrogant thatg u think u can decide what God has said will happen in these Scriptures i have given? Y do Muslims think they know better than God ewhat God should or will do!!!

[The3in1trinity]

Ishmael was a half brother 2 Isaac. God made it clear (NOT CHRISTIANS AS U STATE) that He would bless Ishmael but that the Promise would b made through Isaac!!! Take the time 2 READ WHAT GOD ACTUALLY SAID, NOT WHAT U THINK HE SHOULD HAVE SAID!

Mohammad couldn't b a prophet of God because Ishmael was not not part of the Jewish line. Deuteeronomy chapters 17+18 state that the Prophet had 2 come from the Jewish line or brethren. WHAT GOD SAYS IS WHAT MATTERS, NOT WHAT U THINK HE SHOULD HAVE DONE!

[gerryboy101]

isaac is the winner

[WestleyClydeGarner]

Quit saying Um. If you are going to post videos talk intelligently. We as Christians are not saying Ishmael is not a son of Abraham. God just chose not to mention him in Genesis 22 because he was not of the true line.

[WestleyClydeGarner]

Quit saying Um. If you are going to post videos talk intelligently. We as Christians are not saying Ishmael is not a son of Abraham. God just chose not to mention him in Genesis 22 because he was not of the true line.