Top Comments
All Comments (28)
-
A lovely lady and one of the best singers ever. full stop.
-
I heard it once said 'Our mortal forms are but shadows of a purer reality' Certainly true in Dustys case,she was an angel amongst us,great singer & so beautiful.R.I.P Dusty,give anything to bring you back!
-
Dusty's version is BY FAR the BEST redition of this song. Utterly amazing!
-
RANDY NEWMAN?!?!?
Yeah, I know He wrote the Song, but NO ONE AND I MEAN NO ONE CAN DO ANY SONG BETTER THAN DUSTY SPRINGFIELD!!!!
I SAY FUUUUUHHHH, RANDY NEWMAN!!!!
CANNOT STAND HIM!!!!
-
I love this arrangement of the song. The arranger changes the chords around slightly.
I think Dusty was intelligent enough to understand the song. She felt every song that she chose to sing.
I'm not very bright, but even I get the irony.(Duhhh)
-
Randy Newman songs are always misunderstood... theres always irony..check out Neil Diamonds version.
-
What makes you think she didn't understand the song? The line about 'human kindness overflowing' is in the original lyrics - her delivery of this and 'that's the way to treat a friend' are knowingly ironic. (Watch her expressive hand movement on the latter.) This was a song she fell in love with from a demo-disc by Randy Newman himself and felt closest to personally. Her interpretation is bittersweet and subtly poised. You should give her more credit for being an intelligent artist.
-
She should have covered a song she understood. This is NOT a song about human kindness. Anything but.
-
Piffle if you'd like. She should have covered a song she understood instead of ignoring the lyrics of this one (which she changed). She's a great singer...who shouldn't have touched this song.
-
oh piffle!
Let me offer this opinion: the song is not so much "very, very dark" as sad, bitter, and bittersweet; it is more universal than just "how we all treat the homeless." Nicely sung by Dusty, but listen to Randy Newman singing it--heartbreaking.
Straussian 3 years ago 4
dusty was one of the best vocalists of all time. this is a great performance. john
johnrunion 3 years ago 3