Michael Chapdelaine, Bach prelude bwv 846
Top Comments
All Comments (118)
-
A true masterpiece....
-
I do hear lots of dynamics, emotions and expressions; I don't even understand why there were some self-righteous, blank accounts said he played like a metronome.
Seriously, show us how to NOT play like a metronome; don't just hide behind computer monitor and criticized like you're the best player in the world.
-
I only saw two blank ass accounts criticized a real guitar master.
-
@JonesPeter4 OMG he plays rhythmically. AUTOMATICALLY MEANS NO EXPRESSION. Why is this way of thinking so prevalent. What about his phrasing, and dynamics? and his well balanced sound. This is a beautiful rendition in my opinion. This piece has a constant rhythm throughout and is what i think gives it the sense of movement. i personally think it's fine.
-
Michael uses rubato throughout. I completely dissagree with Smithsherman and Jonespeter4. Maybe you put this through your autotune program while you listened to it? As to classical performers being superficial, would you call an english professor lecturing on Moby Dick superficial? The relation is the same. The superficial in the music world are they who rely on costume and staging to sell "music". Jealous listeners will always attack the truth they cannot realize themselves. Go Michael Go.
-
@JonesPeter4 He's not at all metronomic here - note the subtle changes in volume and speed in the important passages - it take an ear to hear those though...
-
wâhnsînn_lÈÙtê_sûcht_mal_nÁch:
_olikohle_ÄÛf_gø0glE_voll_gèïl -
from Jose the hermeterec.....this is a nice, faithfully executed version of this prelude, but come on......among the best classicasl guitarists in the world????? Surely you say this in jest......
-
I have no complaint of his playing at all. I like youtube because I can listen too music that I could not or would not buy or even know about. It's a shame To turn it into an E-complaint box.
-
flawless timing sounds just fine to me!
This goes on my BACH AS NOSFERATU PLAYLIST.
I'M NOT SURPRISED THAT HE WON THE "CLASSICAL"
COMPETITION...because he imitates to perfection the vapid superficiality of the classical world.
smithsherman 3 years ago 21
@Estonianwoodsman -> smithsherman is absolutely correct. Michael plays Bach like a metronome here. Thus completely empty/vapid; something that is very common among classical musicians today.
To quote Robert Donington: "one of the most stubborn modern misconceptions concerning baroque music is that a metronomic regularity was intended"
JonesPeter4 1 year ago 9