scene from Werckmeister Harmonies by Bela Tarr
Uploader Comments (CAIIIKA)
Top Comments
-
absolutely one of the most powerful things iv ever seen in film.
All Comments (46)
-
TARKOSKY, MICHALANGELO ANTONIONI FUERON UNOS GRANDE SMAESTROS E INPIRADORES. AGREGO A EL ALEMAN . FASSBINDER
-
@ruizj2006 To express the irreal meaning of this scene. It's about the mankind's cruelty until meeting God's powerful force.
-
@interzone3 this is how I read the movie too, except in real life the perpetrators don't stop when confronted by vulnerability. I also inversed the reading, seeing the violent attackers as the working class, sick of being abused, turning to anger and violence, only to be confronted by their own conscience (unlike real perpetrators). So, they leave, unable to kill the greedy old man, to drop the final blow, because they are essentially good. So, they committ themselves to continued poverty.
-
@ettumifilii How could you know that? No specific mention of date or era was made in the film.
-
@edeneye808 ...but it is all about how we accept, without protest, what is done to us...the everyday violence...and finally, the perpetrators...rendered impotent by their confrontation with naked and vulnerable humanity - what they know we are all reduced to, simply leave...incredibly beautiful
-
I am glad that i know Bela's work. Its a secret that i share only with the people that have seen his art.
-
why is the whole scene so quiet?
-
unfathomable talent.
Thanks to the music what starts at 4:48 is one of the most disturbing and simultanously the most beautiful moment I've ever seen in movies. And I saw many. Respect.
Bell1970 1 week ago
@Bell1970 thanks tarr for this
that moment is in most exciting & powerful moments in cinematography i've seen too
CAIIIKA 6 days ago
once onee watches one of Belas films. It cannot be erased from ones memory.
jun7per 3 years ago 19
exactly
CAIIIKA 3 years ago 2