Is Sin A Myth ?
Top Comments
All Comments (684)
-
*naturalistic-ally, not nationalistically
-
Also, the Seven Deadly "Sins" are a set of things that have nationalistically been observed to be evil (except lust. Lust itself causes no harm, it's how one handles their lust that can cause harm). Greed, envy, wrath (not simply anger. wrath. There's a difference.), vanity, gluttony, sloth and mishandled lust have all been observed to lead to deadly situations when left untempered. For example, corporate greed leading to people being unable to pay for cancer treatment.
-
GEERUP, even if you believe morals come from God, you determine whether or not something is good or bad by figuring out if it seems to be helpful or harmful to your ideal world. And that's exactly how morality can arise without God; most of us would like to live in a world without murder, and so we have collectively agreed that murder is evil behavior. And calling evil "sin" implies direct offense to a deity. That's why atheists have a problem with that word. In our eyes, the word is dogmatic.
-
Moral sense is a disease that humans have. Animals do not have a moral sense and they have never had genocides, wars, greed, or lust. Your "God" gave us our moral sense which allow us to "sin".
-
I couldn't agree more with you on the issue of slavery. Be sure to check out Leviticus 25:44-46, Exodus 21:2-6, and Exodus 21:7-11 to see what your Bible has to say on the matter...
-
When we kill civilians then yes we are evil. So are the suicide bombers. When we condones slavery and the rest of the world did as well were we evil for doing so? Yes, now i think there was a lot of ignorance and the reasoning behind it was not always malicious but rather economic, yet still oppressive. So I would say that oppressively taking blacks as slaves against their will was evil even though a majority of the world had no problem at the time.
-
Not true. Hitler was judged by the world-at-large to be evil in his day. The global society. Even within his own society, there were those who disagreed.
But look at the USA today. There are many who consider our presence and actionsin the Middle East to be evil. Are we?
-
Then Hitler wasn't evil in your view, he couldn't be because according to his society he was doing what was right.
-
Sin is essentially synonymous with evil so then does that me to atheists, evil is just an invented idea?
-
there is no such thing as sin. Just whats right and whats wrong and that's relative depending on your perspective.
You talk alot about how christianity think that morals come from some celestial being. Christianity does not have morality, what christianity have is obedience to authority as a substitute for morals.
MrSpleesh 2 years ago 8
@GEERUP
Morality is derived from society. The ancient Greeks has no issue with raping young boys. As recently as the 1800's a gunfight was considered a legal method of dispute resolution. If atheists are correct and there is no afterlife, murder becomes an even more reprehensible act, since the soul has no chance to live on. With regard to the bible's "moral code", I call to your attention: Deuteronomy 17:12, Leviticus 20:13, Leviticus 20:27, Exodus 21:15, Leviticus 20:9, Leviticus 20:10...
mtszabo 1 year ago 4