SCREEN ACTORS GUILD AWARDS 2008.
Top Comments
All Comments (90)
-
@TheAngelmuse SAGrepresents actors votes & they voted for Julie Chrisite, as did Criitcs groups(ie NYFilm Critics, Nat.lSociety, BroadcastFilmCritics, Nat. Board of Review). Unfortunately, with the Oscars 3 weeks away, M.Cotillard went on a "vote for moi, s'il vous plait?" campaign, Oscar voters for the award are variedprofessions(techs, actors, agents)UNrepresentative of the Peers as SAG is. You're also using an incorrect form of "there", should be "their"&her name is Cotillard,notCollitard
-
@shnooger ahh ok cool.... yes PLEASE watch La Vie en Rue. I was not expecting to be taken on a journey of this amazing life, that of Edith Piaf. If you love great perfermances. dont let this one pass you by to long. Anyhow, let me know when you do finally watch. Id love to hear your opinion. You seem to appreciate and know about talented performance. Cate as Elizabeth is one of my favorites roles in film, so im glad you So Enjoyed that film too! Peace .......
-
@TheAngelmuse Oh, OK...cool. But Laura Linney's not one of the nominees here (are you thinking of the Oscars?lol.) Anyway, Julie won for her peformance, not for the overall film...otherwise it would be a different category. I agree with you that Cate shoulda won a decade before. I'll have to watch that Piaf movie one of these days (and maybe I'll say, "Hey, TheAngelMuse is right!"). Marion won the Oscar anyway (the big one!). Peace : )
-
@shnooger This particular year I did watch all the ladies performance in their nominated films. Julie christie was good yes. But the film overall was boring. Cate Blancett is Awsome, but she should of won for the original film of Elizabeth and not Gwenth P. 10 years earlier. Ellen P. was ok. Laura Linney was great. But Marion was AMAZING. Had it not been Marion I think Cate should have won for being robbed 10 years earlier. Marion was that good, she won for a French language film. : )
-
@TheAngelmuse You saw all of the performances?
-
Seriously - Julie Christie over Marion Collitard??? Really ??? NO Way - thank goodness people came around to there senses by the time the Oscars came around. Marions performance doesnt even compare to any other performances of that year. SHE was absolutley amazing! even though the film was in french, she somehow manages to feel the character, the life and music of Edith Piaf. Im still in AWE!
-
Marion should have won
-
@KellyGreen5555 yeah he's a little control freak
-
Josh Brolin is such a little dick.
As a homosexual prostitute with a SAG card,
I'd like to thank Javier for that shout out!
lakevubud 3 years ago 16
Most people express their opinions without having seen all the films and all the performances... I guess there's a film critic in all of us!!! Congrats to Julie Christie (SAG Winner) and Marion Cotillard (Oscar Winner) both of them gave great performances this year!!!
grumpy88888 3 years ago 10