Che resposabilitàdi cantare cio' sulla scala dove Rossini lui stesso fu direttore ! è scritto ne per mezzo ne soprano. In realtà, la prima versione del Teatro di TOrre Argentine (1816) era per mezzo-soprano. Ma quand l'opera fu giocata a Parigi, in A819 poi 1824, si è pensato che il gusto francese era piuttosto alle soprano. Allora fu trasposta per soprano lirico spinto. Avete ragione tutti due !... Ecco.
@emerson4vet@lck0fcolor That's true - this piece was written for a mezzo. There are coloratura mezzos and lots of music in that repertoire. Also, back in the '90s, when this was recorded, they were looser with the styles and didn't always do everything historically correct, the way it's done now. I think she does a nice job with the aria and I think the best singers of this piece are mezzos.
@Emerson4Vet this piece was intended for mezzos. many mezzos do this piece very well. style and voice part are two different things. just because one mezzo didn't get the style quite right doesn't mezzos shouldn't do the piece. joyce didonato is one example of a mezzo that does this piece very well. check her out (:
Che resposabilitàdi cantare cio' sulla scala dove Rossini lui stesso fu direttore ! è scritto ne per mezzo ne soprano. In realtà, la prima versione del Teatro di TOrre Argentine (1816) era per mezzo-soprano. Ma quand l'opera fu giocata a Parigi, in A819 poi 1824, si è pensato che il gusto francese era piuttosto alle soprano. Allora fu trasposta per soprano lirico spinto. Avete ragione tutti due !... Ecco.
SocrateAdmirer 1 week ago
@Emerson4Vet
you are an ignorant ! risina is writing for mezzo o soprano
fantagaro100 3 weeks ago
too pacefuly !
fantagaro100 3 weeks ago
@emerson4vet @lck0fcolor That's true - this piece was written for a mezzo. There are coloratura mezzos and lots of music in that repertoire. Also, back in the '90s, when this was recorded, they were looser with the styles and didn't always do everything historically correct, the way it's done now. I think she does a nice job with the aria and I think the best singers of this piece are mezzos.
cleareyedwolf 2 months ago
@Emerson4Vet this piece was intended for mezzos. many mezzos do this piece very well. style and voice part are two different things. just because one mezzo didn't get the style quite right doesn't mezzos shouldn't do the piece. joyce didonato is one example of a mezzo that does this piece very well. check her out (:
lck0fcolor 2 months ago
Great job, but why is a mezzo doing a coloratura piece? Sure, she's got the notes......wrong style though.
Emerson4Vet 2 months ago
Great voice! God she is so good! but she sings with too much legato
8Goldie 4 months ago
Way to butcher it!
ManIhTwoLinJay 5 months ago
Great voice, a lil over done on teh cadenza's for me.
magicmonkichi 1 year ago
Thanks so much for sharing!;)
ashkay369 2 years ago 2