Scrooge: Charles Dickens' Classic - A Christmas Carol (1935)

DVD: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00006IUIT?ie=UTF8&tag=doc06-20&link... http://thefilmarchived.blogspot.com/

Scrooge is a 1935 film directed by Henry Edwards featuring Seymour Hicks as Ebenezer Scrooge, the miser who hates Christmas. It was the first sound version of the Charles Dickens classic A Christmas Carol, not counting a 1928 short subject that now appears to be lost.

Hicks had played the role of Scrooge on the stage many times beginning in 1901, and again in a 1913 British silent film version. The 1935 film differs from all other versions of the story in one significant way - most of the ghosts, including that of Jacob Marley, are not actually shown onscreen, although their voices are heard. Only the Ghost of Christmas Present (Oscar Asche) is actually seen in full figure - the Ghost of Christmas Past is a mere shape with no discernible facial features, Marley's Ghost is seen only briefly as a face on the door knocker, and the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come is just an outstretched pointing finger.

Why the film was made this way remains unclear; it is obviously not due to the fact that British filmmakers could not achieve special effects, since we do see Marley's face superimposed on Scrooge's door knocker.

Another aspect making this film different from other versions of the story is that Seymour Hicks plays both the old and young Scrooge, rather straining the credulity of the audience, since by this time, the sixty-four year old actor was visibly too aged to convincingly play a young man.

The story is also severely truncated, even more than in the 1938 MGM film version, although the 1935 version is actually slightly longer. Much time is spent at the beginning of the film - before any of the ghosts appear - setting up the atmosphere of rich and poor London. Scrooge's sister Fan and Fezziwig are completely omitted from this version.

This is the first of only two sound versions in which Tiny Tim is actually seen lying dead. In the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come sequence Bob Cratchit grieves at Tim's bedside. The 1999 Patrick Stewart version also contains this scene.

Maurice Evans appears briefly as a man harassed by Scrooge to pay his debts. Donald Calthrop portrays a Bob Cratchit who bears an uncanny physical resemblance to John Leech's illustrations of the character in the original 1843 edition of the novel.

Two versions of this film exist; each has a differently designed opening credits sequence, and one of the two versions omits the very last scenes.

Cast * Seymour Hicks - Ebenezer Scrooge (as Sir Seymour Hicks) * Donald Calthrop - Bob Cratchit * Robert Cochran - Fred * Mary Glynne - Belle * Garry Marsh - Belle's husband * Oscar Asche - Spirit of Christmas Present * Marie Ney - Spirit of Christmas Past * C.V. France - Spirit of Christmas Future * Athene Seyler - Scrooge's charwoman * Maurice Evans - Poor man * Mary Lawson - Poor man's wife * Barbara Everest - Mrs. Cratchit * Eve Gray - Fred's wife * Morris Harvey - Poulterer with Prize Turkey * Philip Frost - Tiny Tim

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• scrooge
• christmas
• compassion
• period
• piece
• 1840s
• redemption
• victorian
• era
• ghost
• based
• on
• novel
• character
• ebenezer
• seymour
• hicks
• donald
• calthrop
• robert
• cochran
• mary
• glynne
• garry
• marsh
• oscar
• asche
• marie
• ney
• c.v.
• france
• athene
• seyler
• maurice
• evans
• lawson
• barbara
• everest
• eve
• gray
• morris
• harvey
• phillip
• frost
• bob
• cratchit
• spirit
• present
• past
• future
• broadway
• tango
• russia
• waltz
• advent
• animated
• avril
• avril lavigne
• lavigne

[Layna8]

I love these old black & white versions of A Christmas Carol...I grew up with Alastair Sim's version every Christmas...it has always had a great impact on me spiritually...I became a Christian over 35 years ago, I would say, partly due to this movie. God Bless Us, Everyone.

L. Please think of someone and do for someone else, this Christmas...it may mean life or death to someone this Season...

[RascalCoyote]

this is one of the worst versions in my opinion. the spirit of Christmas present is completely out of character., no where near as joyous as he's supposed to be.

[edwinspiteri]

A very good even though it is an old one.

[Strateg68]

Greed is good?

[hollyannblss]

One of the best versions! Wonder how many others are hiding in the dusty shelves of history. Thx for sharing and have a loving holiday!

[YamatoHenge]

@Layna8 A great idea to do something nice for others! I sent out 130 Christmas cards through a prison penpal project! Was great, I am already reaping what I soe most have written back with a big thank you and that it made their day because they do not ussually get Christmas cards! So EVERYONE do something nice, go out of your way to be kind to someone and you will feel great about it!! :o)

[TheProudAmerican777]

hearing "God Save The King" makes me feel like yelling" God Save The Empire"!

[Garrettk41]

@reggaejuggler I don't quite get what you mean by that, but either way, you're wrong about Michael Hordern. He played Jacob Marley, not the past ghost, and that was in the Alistair Sim version.

[reggaejuggler]

@Garrettk41

I think the ghost (Michael Hordern) uses his own voice maybe?

[tucsondog]

6:00 - 6:30 is my favourite part!

[Garrettk41]

For the reccord, Marie Ney doesn't voice the Ghost of Christmas Past. She's just the physical outline. As anyone should be able to tell, that's a man's voice.