I thought my answer clear, I didn't know Ms Eder so I listened to make an informed reply, my reply after listening was a polite way of saying I still feel Sumi Jo's was the first I had heard by a "real" singer.
My personal view and I add "my personal view" is that Ms Eder is perhaps 20% the singer Sumi Jo is. Don't take offense at this. Many people are less than complimentary about Sumi Jo, I just view them as blinkered philistines, you are welcome to view me the same.
@rmcinuk Well, Sumi Jo is my music too. I love her!
Just, I don't understand your first comment. If you don't know Linda Eder (which is the leading performer of this song), what you mean with "a rendition of this performed by a" real "singer"?
Must admit she is not someone I knew about.. I am always open to new listening experiences, so following your reply I have listened to several of her pieces.
I can only say she from my view point, she is better than lots of singers who follow the career path she has taken.
@LordoftheTrapdoors
I thought my answer clear, I didn't know Ms Eder so I listened to make an informed reply, my reply after listening was a polite way of saying I still feel Sumi Jo's was the first I had heard by a "real" singer.
My personal view and I add "my personal view" is that Ms Eder is perhaps 20% the singer Sumi Jo is. Don't take offense at this. Many people are less than complimentary about Sumi Jo, I just view them as blinkered philistines, you are welcome to view me the same.
rmcinuk 5 months ago
@rmcinuk Well, Sumi Jo is my music too. I love her!
Just, I don't understand your first comment. If you don't know Linda Eder (which is the leading performer of this song), what you mean with "a rendition of this performed by a" real "singer"?
LordoftheTrapdoors 5 months ago
@LordoftheTrapdoors
Must admit she is not someone I knew about.. I am always open to new listening experiences, so following your reply I have listened to several of her pieces.
I can only say she from my view point, she is better than lots of singers who follow the career path she has taken.
Thank goodness for diversity.
Enjoy your music as I enjoy mine.
Sumi Jo stills rules in my world!
rmcinuk 5 months ago
@rmcinuk Wait. Do you really think Linda Eder isn't a REAL singer?
LordoftheTrapdoors 6 months ago
Nice to hear a rendition of this performed by a "real" singer
Sumi Jo forever
rmcinuk 8 months ago