Rachmaninoff Piano Concerto No 5 - Denis Matsuev 1st mov part I
Uploader Comments (SergRach1)
Video Responses
All Comments (44)
-
I really oppose the idea of calling it "Rachmaninoff Piano Concerto #5" because in no way is it a Rachmaninoff piano concerto. With that said this is a wonderfully beautiful transcription true to the style of Rachmaninoff.
-
First of all Thanks for posting. Extremely interesting but in the end I think the arrangement is horrible and does no service at all to the symphony. The piano writing often sounds more like Bath's Cornish Rhapsody or The Warsaw Concerto, sometimes it's simply meretricious. The piano & orchestra version of the Dminor piano trio is far superior as a "new" Rachmaninov concerto.
-
@1Thompsonmusic Well I didn't exactly command you to listen to her, did I? I only said that I enjoy the solo performance more, and as there is only one solo performance in YouTube (Lisitsa's) I recommended hers. I might be wrong, though - I haven't checked the entire YouTube for solo performances of this concerto...
And by the way, Valentina is amazing. :P But that's just my opinion.
-
OMG, is he reading from sheet music?
-
Awesome! I didn´t know that this transcription exists. Symphony 2, the best than others. (FROM ARG)
-
Awesome! I didn´t know that this transcription exist. Symphony 2, the best than others. (FROM ARG)
-
This piece was originally a simphony (2 in E minor sorry). I always think in the simphony like a masterpiece, but the work of Warenberg in the transcription is equally great. Probably he doesn´t give anything new, but i think it´s just like Rachmaninoff should do if he wanted a piano concerto. Many people don´t like the idea of a piano concerto with a pice wich originally wasn´t. I think that many composers incluiding Rach take pieces from others and make variations and other works.
This transcription is magnificent! I can't help but listen to it nearly eveyday. My Itouch showed that within couple f months I have listened to the whole concerto about 1400 times. I've been looking for the piano score for a long time, does anyone have it?
Vampianist3 4 months ago
@Vampianist3 Boosey & Hawkes! :)
SergRach1 2 weeks ago