Maulid with Habib Umar Bin Hafiz
Top Comments
All Comments (105)
-
@TShaikh05 .hw can individuals with limited knowledge declare virtuous acts as bidah sayyiah-they claim to b followers of authentic scholars+yet arent acquainted with their teachings.they claim 2 lov the prophet saw yet shun his praises.they claim to propogate 'true' islam yet have little knowledge on it. wrld renowned authorities dont debate on these issues as they are clear cut. society is full of damaging,unqualifid ppl who detatch ppl from true islam and away from th love of the prophet saw
-
@TShaikh05 the main innovations intro at that time were false prophets,apostasy,tribes refusing to pay zakat etc-these acts lead the perpertrators outside the folds of islam. from this its absurd to categorise all innovations as misguidance. the prophet saw was talking about new acts which would cause apostasy to prevail+mischeif to spread. how can the celebration of the prophet saw be comparable to apostasy? to fully understand 'bidah' one must have knowledge of its technical+legal meanings
-
@TShaikh05 b4 throwing the word 'bidah' around study its linguistic meaning. frm the hadith u presented it distinguishes between types of actions that cn be deemed bidah. frm earlier eg its clear tht not every innovated matter is a misguidance. in the hadith the prophet saw suggests that the innovations he is discussing r those which will take place in his time+immediately after his holy demise. if we look at the main innovations intro at that time, they were bidah sayyiah(offensive innovation)
-
@TShaikh05 u are obviously not aware of bidah hasanah?(good innovation) there are so many examples of them bidah waajibah are necessary innovations- a new action which if omitted can lead to critical complications in the religion; e.g. the addition of vowels in the quran, the principles of quranic tafsir, sciences of hadith, establishment of islamic educational institutions= all 'bidah' by your definition as they werent present at tym of saw.+by ur mentality they shouldnt have been introduced?
-
@TShaikh05 alhamdhulillah most of the people i knw who partake in mawlids do everythng u said+more.whats more is tht they r pple filled with love.do u really think ur guaranteed jannah so u do not have to do anything extra?ur refusing an extra opportunity to praise the prophet saw is basically what your saying+that to me is really sad. muslims are known for being filled with love, always striving to do more, to please allah swt. dont u think allah will love u if you love what he loves the most?
-
@TShaikh05 the mawlid increases faith, reminds those who have fallen, increases love and brotherhood amongst people, unites people. does this sound like its against the sunnah? seriously? instead of being brainwashed by people, think for yourself, look at the essence of a mawlid. its beautiful. and who said those partaking in mawlid dont follow the prophet saw? mawlids REMIND people to do exactly what you just said. to embrace the prophet saw's character. to love. to be kind. to be merciful.
-
@TShaikh05 scholars agree that bidah is any new deed or action which finds no source either directly or indirectly in the quran+sunnah- people like you confine'bidah'to always have a negative implication.to any one with rationality they could gather that frm the hadith u presented, the prophet saw meant smthing that has absolutely no source in the quran+sunnah+has negatve implications+impacts on islam. again,look at the essence of a mawlid= every single practice is deriven from the quran+sunnah
-
@ilovchocolate100 The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) told us of that, as it was narrated that ‘Aa’ishah (may Allaah be pleased with her) said: “The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: ‘Whoever innovates something in this matter of ours [i.e., Islam] that is not part of it will have it rejected.’” (Narrated by al-Bukhaari, Kitaab al-Sulh, 2499).
Our master Jesus was sent for the Children of Israel only
Our master Muhammad sallallahu alayhi wasallam was sent for the whole of mankind
qas86 2 years ago 10
my beautiful brother in this deen
we don't "read" our deen, we SIT at the feet hnourably infront of scholars (asking those who are in authority, in al-Qur'an) who have spent their entire lives studying and passing on via unbroken chains to the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wasallam.
I don't need to argue about the mawlid; sometimes it is very difficult for people to accept due to their egos. But if the scholars allow it, then what's wrong?
The difference lies in the word "bid'ah"
qas86 2 years ago 4