Leonid Brumberg plays Brahms Fantasies Op.116 (1/3)
Uploader Comments (nikolaimedtner)
Top Comments
-
everyone who says he uses too much rubato, fuck you, its romantic music, you dont play this kind of music like a click track, like baroque, everyone who thinks so doesn't actually feel the music and has no sense of musicianship, only technically created...
Video Responses
All Comments (15)
-
La tendenza al rubato con una certa variabilità, l'elasticità e l'incertezza "voluta" in certe pause, fanno pensare molto di più a Robert Schumann... oppure i Pezzi op. 116 sono proprio un omaggio ufficiale di Johannes Brahms al suo amico e collega ? Leonid Brumberg è stato strepitoso e innovativo in Liszt e in Liapounov, ma con Brahms ha voluto ... cambiare pagina in fatto di stesura interpretativa ? Mistero !
-
@yadro63 Then get a hearing aid, and something that approaches at least adequate musical training. Until then, don't waste your time trying to figure out anything you are incapable of understanding.
-
@triviummusician Well said. This great performance rivals that of Walter Klien for its orchestral dimensions, rhythmic flexibility that obliterates bar lines in favor of affective nuance and a cumulative rhythm that moves the hemiolas inexorably forward.
-
@Barbapippo And what a pity you're all washed up.
-
what a pity that it sounds like someone playing under water...
-
Tempo fluctuations in this period were normal! Playing ths metronomically is much worse. Go listen to Ilona Eibenschütz play 119/2 -- she studied with Clara Schumann and premiered some late Brahms (118 and 119, I think).
-
Funny--I've heard the same! Personally, I have more affinity for his shorter piano works and chamber music. He seems to utilize the individual instruments to their full potential. The choral and orchestral pieces seem long-winded and I lose my interest. Maybe it's just me. Thanks for posting this incredible performance.
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Mais c'est horrible comme Bramhs,il fait plein de rubato,c'est inapproprier
Messiaen28 2 years ago
rubato "inapproprier" dans Brahms??....
nikolaimedtner 2 years ago 4
and people say Brahms is dull!
morvensky 2 years ago
it depends on who plays it :)
nikolaimedtner 2 years ago