Rachmaninoff - Etude-tableau Op.33 No.5 in D minor
Uploader Comments (konzolmester)
Top Comments
-
Op. 33 no. 4 is missing from the original score; so there technically is no No. 4, though many people incorrectly label this as No. 4.
Video Responses
All Comments (56)
-
ive heard that in the original classic recordings its named no4, but i bought the score and it was name no5, i agree that there is no point in arguing its number, especially when its so beautiful. giving it a number just makes it easier to locate, now it has two numbers its all the easier!
thankyou Rachmaninov for giving us this Etude.
-
Rachmaninoff's intention with this series of etudes was to paint a different picture in your head for each one.
The picture that is painted here is of rain.
-
Does seem very fantastical. I wish I could play this piece this well...
-
@Iamfromsweden007 I agree. Especially 2:14 sounds like the best combination of piano keys I've ever heard.
-
wow....sounds mysterious...
-
this is etude tableaux 4 op 33
-
This is by far my favourite, Rachmaninoff was an utter genius. Those harmonies make the hairs on the back of my neck stand up :)
This is so wonderful. Especially around 2.14 - AMAZING. I can't belive there's hasn't been any comments yet on how beautful this piece is. Instead you have been arguing if it's no. 4 or no. 5.
Iamfromsweden007 2 years ago 25
Yes. They should take a look on wikipedia. These op.33 Etudes and numberings are VALID and these videos are linked as example on wikipedia.
konzolmester 2 years ago
Precisely. Therefore stop arguing about the number please.
konzolmester 2 years ago