Leonid Sobinov - Средь шумного бала (at the ball) - 1910
Uploader Comments (RADAMES1983)
Video Responses
All Comments (23)
-
@RADAMES1983 Таких уродов, как ты, нужно уничтожать.
-
this is the best version. grande Sobinov!
-
Are you kidding me? Reizen was beautiful!
-
SUBLIME!
-
@deramr I like many singers from the "USSR". I just don't like Reizen. REIZEN, get it?
-
Here is a link of Pinza groaning and growling (you can call it acting).
watch?v=CYKFkwFmbac
You are free to have your own opinion, as wrong as it is, but it is very clear to me that you have an agenda of some sort when it comes to singers from the USSR. Reizen was taught by Federico Bugamelli, not Joseph Stalin.
-
@deramr I don't recall Alexander Kipnis, Ezio Pinza, Tancredi Pasero or Wilhelm Strienz being gruff or grumbly. Maybe you are thinking of some Soviet figures. Reizen has many admirers. I'm not one of them.
-
gruff? grumblings? in an era were all basses, not just those from the USSR, were busy being gruff and grumbly, Mark Reizen was one of the most glorious exceptions to the rule. The man never compromised on his vocal production or musical line.
I really have to wonder whether you've taken the time to actually listen to Reizen's interpretation of this song before slighting one of the finest basses of his time. It's on youtube.
-
Great romance and great artist! Thank you for this!
- на мой взгляд ужасно безвкусное пение, масса кривляний и преувеличений (особенно ужасно в Верди, Пуччини и вообще любом иностранном репертуаре), Какой то шепот и неестественность.
У нас достаточно много певцов которыми можно гордиться, и Козловский не в их числе.
RADAMES1983 4 years ago
Собинов - Это великолепно...
На счет Козловского не могу с вами согласиться, и не могу его слушать (кроме Юродивого - Там он поет сам себя... )
Высокогортанный крик, никакой настоящий вокальной (оперной!)техники, а главное
RADAMES1983 4 years ago