Plantinga - Dennett 1
Loading...
Loading...
10,952
Uploaded by SisyphusRedeemed on Mar 7, 2009
Alvin Plantinga (Notre Dame) delivers a paper at the 2009 Central Division of the American Philosophical Association in Chicago, entitled "Religion and Science: Where the Real Conflict Lies." Daniel Dennett (Tufts) comments.
No, this is not my recording, but yes, I was at this talk (I actually ask the very first question in the Q&A (I didn't express myself well, but Plantinga seemed to get the jist). I tried to record it, but my camera wasn't working. So I found this recording online, and thought the YouTube community might enjoy.
- 37 likes, 8 dislikes
-
Link to this comment:
Share to:
Loading...
- 0:46Cthulhu Strongby SisyphusRedeemed4,093 views
- 55:37What's so Queer About Gay Marriage?by SisyphusRedeemed4,793 views
- 18:51Death Penalty Follow Upby SisyphusRedeemed3,511 views
- 13:09The Death Penalty and the Strange Paradox of In...by SisyphusRedeemed4,994 views
- 10:00Charlie Rose: Dan Dennett - Breaking the Spell ...by NonServiam29,727 views
- 9:29Plantinga - Dennett 2by SisyphusRedeemed1,802 views
- 10:59Atheist's arguments against the existence of Go...by AndreMijail9,513 views
- 10:45Alvin Plantinga vs Daniel Dennett - Part 1by philosophyreligion7,496 views
- 8:36Plantinga - Dennett 9by SisyphusRedeemed859 views
- 8:01Plantinga - Dennett 4by SisyphusRedeemed979 views
- 10:54Daniel Dennett on William Lane Craigby riversonthemoon122,302 views
- 5:07Ontological Argumentby semperadlucem30,771 views
- 20:00What is a Properly Basic Belief? (Alvin Plantinga)by rfvidz7,606 views
- 1:20:40Evolutionary Argument Against Naturalism: The D...by rfvidz2,934 views
- 4:35plantinga 1.mp4by bobdabilderful432 views
- 10:54Evolutionary Argument Against Naturalism (1 of ...by philosophyreligion4,958 views
- 1:25Plantinga the Final Wordby scepticthinker183 views
- 6:05Alvin Plantinga and the Mind-Body Problemby LennyBound6,915 views
- 2:06Famous Atheist Antony Flew Changes Mind, Believ...by shadfewl153,680 views
- 7:49J P Moreland : Skepticism and Epistemology 8 of...by grandconjunct3,721 views
@CrateofStolenDirt, yes. The CT story is extensive. I'm currently working on a video about it that will explain.
DarkMatter2525 3 months ago
@dooyeweerd, well, well, well. I'm getting messages from good Christians on the inside saying that CT supporters are planning a flagging campaign, and that they're contacting people they know who work for youtube to try to get me shut down. To protect troll accounts?! Not likely. I can see that this is going to get really, really ugly. And to think, it could've all been over, but NOOOOOOOOO. You couldn't have that. You never learn, do you?
DarkMatter2525 3 months ago
there is a vid of plantinga giving the very same talk at biola, with good vid quality
demonstrationclass8 4 months ago
@TheFlamingPromethean
I suspect they would say because God helps those who help themselves.
Avicenna10 5 months ago
Actions speak louder than words:
Why do Christians (who believe in an omnipotent loving father figure) put lightning rods on their churches?
TheFlamingPromethean 8 months ago
@NinjaMatie
I responded to Plantinga's argument here:
watch?v=eU-wpNOyuas
I got better sound quality on another presentation of basically the same argument.
zarkoff45 8 months ago
Did Plantinga retire? He's still on the Notre Dame website. I would have loved to take one of his classes; he sounds like he is a really entertaining professor.
Dennett, on the other hand, would probably bore me to tears.
rumblefishism 11 months ago
@dinkipooxa First off, it's Plantinga that's speaking in this clip, not Dennett. Second, I assure you that both Plantinga and Dennett are well aware of the ambiguities of the term 'belief' and the difficulties of a clear definition of the term--they've both published on the topic in peer reviewed journals. But when giving a public lecture you cannot digress into conceptual analysis of every term, even the central ones, since doing so would take up all your time. Some terms need to be granted.
SisyphusRedeemed 1 year ago