Top Comments
All Comments (10)
-
Perfección, belleza, joya invaluable, obra maestra,etc etc...Que mas se puede decir de esta canción es magnifica y todo se lo debemos agradecer al genio de Brian Wilson y al maestro Jack Rieley; yo estoy seguro que esta es mas una canción de Rieley que de Wilson, sino escuchen el disco solista de Jack: Western Justice' de 1975 y después díganme, un muy recomendable disco, perdonen fanáticos de los Beach Boys solo trato de reivindicar a un genio pocas veces reconocido. Gracias Jack Rieley!!!
-
Para mi esta es la mejor canción de los Beach Boys en toda su historia y mis fundamentos son que esta demuestra como ninguna otra canción lo mal que estaba Brian, compone después de un tiempo y lo haca tanto con Rieley como con Van Dyke Park, los demás que nunca apoyaron a Brian en especial Mike Love no participan y si lo hace alguien que si siempre estuvo como lo fue Al Jardine y lo hace como nunca antes lo había escuchado, las melodias del organo y el melotron del intermedio son epicas, Genios
-
@itsstillfriday I also always assumed it was a depressed Brian...!
-
The most poignant moment of this recording occurs at 2:40 when Brian chimes in with his "Oh Lord I Lay Me Down, My Branches To The Ground" tag. It marks the last time his voice would still sound more like Carl's than like Dennis's.
-
That's Jack Rieley singing lead, not Brian. And Van Dyke Parks can be heard on the tag, "Trees like me..."
-
I always thought this was one of Brian's transitional vocals between his angelic 60's efforts and his 70's cigarette and booze soaked era ... Rieley did a fine job with it, and it's a song I've always liked, including the calliope sounds. In fact, nearly all of 'Surfs Up' is wonderful ...
-
So Amazing!
-
A gorgeous song. Wish Brian had written so much more back then.
The "Oh Lord I Lay Me Down" high part is Al Jardine from what I understand. Regardless, i find that one of most moving moments in all of Brian Wilson/Beach Boys' music -- that's saying a lot. A very misunderstood and unappreciated track -- brilliantly sad.
Misterhappynyc 2 months ago 3
WoW!! I always thought it was a depressed Brian singing.... same idea as with the haunting demo "Still I Dream of It" ... 20 years later I learn that Riley sang this... hmmm wow... wild to learn new things about stuff you thought you already knew!!
itsstillfriday 2 months ago 2