Idol Soup! Season 9 Episode 19 (TOP 8 GIRLS PERFORM!!!)

Go Subscribe To Mikey!!!
http://www.youtube.com/jkkids

Submit Questions/Videos to:
molliejevans@gmail.com

Yawwwwnnnnnn...what did you guys think? The poor girls probably felt so rushed because this episode went ridiculously fast. It wasn't the best night yet, but there were still a few bright moments. Here's the list of performances:

1. Katie Stevens - "Breakaway" by Kelly Clarkson

2. Siobhan Magnus - "House Of The Rising Sun" by The Animals

3. Lacey Brown - "The Story" by Brandi Carlisle

4. Katelyn Epperly - "I Feel The Earth Move" by Carole King

5. Didi Benami - "Rhiannon" by Fleetwood Mac

6. Paige Miles - "Smile" by Charlie Chaplin

7. Crystal Bowersox - "Give Me One Reason" by Tracey Chapman

8. Lilly Scott - "I Fall To Pieces" by Patsy Cline

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• american
• idol
• soup
• season
• nine
• top
• eight
• girls
• performances
• perform
• full
• episode
• high
• quality
• definition
• hd
• hq
• thoughts
• commentary
• recap
• review
• katie
• stevens
• breakaway
• siobhan
• magnus
• house
• of
• the
• rising
• sun
• lacey
• brown
• story
• katelyn
• epperly
• feel
• earth
• move
• didi
• benami
• rhiannon
• paige
• miles
• smile
• charlie
• chaplin
• crystal
• bowersox
• give
• me
• one
• reason
• lilly
• scott
• fall
• to
• pieces
• semifinals
• hollywood

[jillianjiggs84]

Holla from Toronto! I actually liked that it was 1 hour-less camera hogging by the judges. I'm worried though that the judges are pimping Crystal too much and that will backlash. My rankings:

1. Crystal

2. Siobhan

3. Didi

4. Lilly

5. Katelyn

6. Katie

7. Lacey

8. Paige

I constantly forget that Lacey and Paige are even there. And yeah I associated 'Smile' with MJ too. Even though Paige has been at the bottom lately, I suspect they will keep her this week, and Lacey and a surprise will go home.

[mjesings]

that's a good point, they are definitely pimping her...it's going to make people turn on her.

[yrwehere4]

I actually liked this episode. The only performance I hated was Paige. Who sings a happy song like that sooo morosely? Think she's going. Think Katie or Katelyn is the other going...Crystal, Siobhan and Lilly are still my favorites. (Disagree about Lilly. Thought the Patsy Cline was cool and unusual.) Didi & Lacey did amazingly too. Wonder if it's enough to keep Lacey in. Thought she would have been voted off before now.

[mjesings]

yup lacey might have just saved herself this week with that performance..

[MYnameis150]

Even though I kind of like them I hope that Katie and Paige will go home because I love the other 6!

[mjesings]

me too!

[brianok01]

@fran9 im sorry. i like david cook myself. but i think carrie rules over all. didnt man to make ya mad.

[fran9]

@brianok01 i'm sorry, that's your opinion and you have no right to tell me that "i'm waay off". In my opinion, siobhan is an annoying banshee who just can't stop screaming like she's giving birth. david archuleta is okay, little teen pop star. chris daughtry is amazing, love him. clay blah. all of the rest are fellow idol champions

[brianok01]

@fran9 before carrie underwood, kelly clarkson, chris daughtry, fantasia, clay aiken, siobhan magnus, and david archuleta? hahaha nope. ur waaayyy off.

[Bobjoe225]

1. Siobhan Magnus

2. Crystal Bowersox

3. Didi Benami

4. Katelyn Epperly

5. Lilly Scott

6. Katie Stevens

7. Lacey Brown

8. Paige Miles

[sublimelyardent]

re a capella - chances are she has an ear monitor that gives her the pitch -

probably the trickiest entrance of any so far this season is micheal lynche's on This Women's Work" - he has to enter on a note that fills in an unusual chord

crystal, the love child of janis joplin and eric clapton, is, imho, already a complete artist - i would put her on the stage w/ neil young, mick jagger, etc w/ confidence she would shine.

siobhan second - needs a bit more seasoning but great potential

[Kara899]

Loved everything you said about Crystal. She is truly amazing

[fran9]

best american idol contestant ever: david cook

totally agree

[griffsshu]

Awesome video....and OMG your in B-low now!!!! Your in my neck of the woods lol....woot!

[0xTRellyx0]

I happy you finally liked Didi...I love her.

[8897670]

spot-on girl, good job....