♫ Lord of the Rings - Lament for Haldir (with lyric)
Uploader Comments (PeepMeowMusic)
Top Comments
-
*cries* poor haldir why did he have to die?
-
Oh man, this is short, but heartwrenching - very well done.
Video Responses
All Comments (39)
-
Thank God no haters! :)))
-
@TheTwilightUnicorn oh i know i've read and own all three books. :) but still it's sad peter jackson kills him.
-
@KittyKatHill Well, if my memory still serves me well, Haldir didn't die in the book version of "Lord of the Rings", but was very much alive instead, even in the last stages of the story. And I also seem to remember that the Elves never went to defend the Helm's Deep.
-
@TheMrMilla thx :)
-
he didn't have to die :'(
-
We will miss u haldir, may you go to the undying lands (heaven). Rest in peace.
-
@PeepMeowMusic YES. thank you lol She has such a lovely voice X)
-
@PeepMeowMusic well that's cool. From everything I've read pronunciation is based off scandanavian languages, and going off that knowledge these lyrics aren't that off. But, again, I'm going off my own knowledge of Tolkien's languages :)
From everything I've ever heard or read the songwriters were really close to Tolkien's pronunciations. Maybe there are minor mis pronunciations of vowels here or there in some songs, but I think that could also count as a difference in accent when speaking whichever elvish dialect, maybe even the singer's natural accent coming out. I don't want to get heat for this, I'm just going off what I've learned on a personal basis while studying Tolkien on my own time :)
gwyndolynelizabeth 3 weeks ago
@gwyndolynelizabeth /watch?v=6de_SbVUVfA caita is clearly pronounced different here. most parts of the language are pronounced like in german. for example the different "ch" parts, or how the e and a sounds... And I would pronouce the lyrics very often.. very different ;)
PeepMeowMusic 3 weeks ago
@PeepMeowMusic I did originally think something about Caita sounded off, but mainly because of the vowel sound. But then, the dipthong ai is pronounced with emphasis on the first vowel, so I guess what I'm hearing is maybe the singer's accent?? I think she has one if it's who I think it is... lol can't remember her name!
gwyndolynelizabeth 3 weeks ago
@gwyndolynelizabeth Elizabeth Fraser ;)
PeepMeowMusic 3 weeks ago