ProgFest '09 - One For The Vine

The epic Genesis tune from the Wind and Wuthering album. Drums - Robert Caldwell, Guitar - Chris Lawley, Lead Vox - Brad Gent, Bass - Jason Dionne, Keys - Joel Noftle

Category:

Music

Tags:

• Genesis
• Yes
• King Crimson
• Gentle Giant
• Prog

[panddsboy]

Brilliant job, guys. Not an easy tune by any means. A suggestion only because it really sounds like accuracy is important to you. On the last solo piano section chords, you might try Bmaj ......to D#minor with A# in the bass .......to G#minor to .....Emaj 7 with a passing 6 to 5 resolution. Truly an amazing job, though. Hats off!

[jfn71]

@panddsboy Thanks! Ya, it was quite a project getting this one together. Thanks for your suggestion - I took another look at my final keys part and could hear the G# minor suggestion (with b in the bass I am assuming) and adjusted a couple notes. Not sure what you mean by the D# minor with A# in the bass - I'm sure you could show me better on music notation as trying to describe it in a youtube comment has its limitations :)

[chris21125150]

Joel, you play this all so wonderfully, but I must say, especially the last little bit on piano. Brilliant! :) I miss practicing with you! :(

[jfn71]

@chris21125150 Thanks man!

[ginises83]

Perfect but the drummer is bad

[sarcee1960]

Choice.

Lead singer should be replaced. I know a guy named Phil. Give him a go.

[prosoloist]

Fantastic beyond belief

[SHAKEDOWN72]

f**ckin' awsome you guys!!