We're All Atheists!

Some Atheist apologists make the claim that were all Atheists, even Theists, since we reject other gods. But is this the case?

www.ilovemuhammed.com

Category:

Education

Tags:

• Atheist
• Atheism
• Richard
• Dawkins
• Theist
• Muslim
• Christian
• Jew
• Believer
• God
• Concept
• Nature
• Attributes
• Existence
• Premise
• Belief
• Argument
• Debate
• Truth

[grekounas]

When a Christian and a Muslim debate theology, it reminds me of when I was a kid and I would debate with my friends who would win in a real fight, Optimus Prime or Megatron... That would be epic! Or how about Zeus and Odin? That would be pretty cool too. People of faith are arguing on the basis on non-facts. Proven, scientific facts!

[SamiZaatari]

@grekounas terminator vs robocop. :)

[captaindisguise]

Follow this hypothetical scenario

You believe in Allah

Allah is nothing more than Muhammad's imagination hence not real

The real god is Eashwar from the Vedas

You do not believe in Eashwar hence you have no belief in (the actual) god

Hence you are an atheist

The claim is not supposed to go beyond this. Atheist are not saying you lack belief in a god. So your video was nothing but a strawman!

"Atheists are half muslims" - LOL, many muslims do make that cute and silly and meaningless claim

[npsari]

Make them shorter. But good video.

[focusontheargument]

Nice video again.. but atheists do point at the unprovable element of theology.

[1990PatMorrison]

@SamiZaatari The point was you don't believe in the existence of their gods. Islam describes a very specific god and this is not the same as that of the Hindus.  This argument would only be valid if you were debating another follower of the Abrahamic religion and the argument that you're arguing for the existence of a creator would only hold any Merritt in a deistic perspective

[TTut21]

I've watched a few of this dorks videos... He's right on this one though.

[EarwiggoAgain]

What a boring old fart Sami has become!

[letsdebate1983]

@comslave Umm..Going by this "logic" if I read Dan Brown and you read Agatha Christie, from my perspective you read nothing at all and vice versa? So I think that argument is made just for the sake of arguing..

[comslave]

Disagreeing about god is in fact believing in a different god. Since there is no common frame of reference (IE a real god) then all we have is two separate and unique beliefs. Hence, one person is atheist to the other person's god.