ich bin kein Kenner, ich hab keine Ahnung von Toccata, Preludium or whatsoever und ich kenne die technischen Begebenheiten innerhalb, um, oder mit einer Orgel nicht, kurz gesagt, ich bin ein musikalisch gesehener blutiger Laie... Aber dieses Stück klingt..., und ich betone...KLINGT..., einfach hervorragend, auf dieser Orgel und von diesem Organisten gespielt. Man kann tatsächlich jeden einzelnen Ton hören. Jedes anders eingelegte Tempo (remember: whatsoever...) wäre wahrscheinlich deplatziert.
@mihihi What, as in it is not as fast as how the pianists play it? You have to keep in mind that we organists have to deal with acoustics which sometimes hang around for like seven seconds once a note as been sounded. If you play in an building with alot of acoustic such as Köln Kathedral at prestissimo, the piece would not make any sense at all because it will be all a blur of noise.
hehe...I experienced the same think when I played Bach-Gounod Ave Maria on wedding in chatedral...there is no delay on 1st and 2nd manual, but 3rd!...delay of 1sec!!...hard to keep concetration but everything went fine at the end.......I playing Widor Toccata too...pretty easy but effectively peace
@gorunlove I entirely agree with you! All the drama, too, is beautfully clear: definition...mmmm, I remember playing an organ, which had a terrible delay....it was the Widor Tocatta, I was all of fourteen, not an organist, nor had I played that organ before; my friend signalled for me to keep going; I could do nothing but not dare to listen and play on HA!!
haha...you make me lough...put a piano in that chatedral and play this piece...I don't think that you will play in original tempo because of acoustic....I think that is pretty nice tempo and you can hear everything whats happeninig inside compared with so high-performace piano version where you can't hear anything else but pile of sound
The videos are nice, but this piece is certainly being played awfully slowly! Are the various organs in the cathedral interconnected, or are we hearing only the organ hanging off the triforium wall?
ich bin kein Kenner, ich hab keine Ahnung von Toccata, Preludium or whatsoever und ich kenne die technischen Begebenheiten innerhalb, um, oder mit einer Orgel nicht, kurz gesagt, ich bin ein musikalisch gesehener blutiger Laie... Aber dieses Stück klingt..., und ich betone...KLINGT..., einfach hervorragend, auf dieser Orgel und von diesem Organisten gespielt. Man kann tatsächlich jeden einzelnen Ton hören. Jedes anders eingelegte Tempo (remember: whatsoever...) wäre wahrscheinlich deplatziert.
Marcus29Essen 14 hours ago
eine der besten Interpretationen der neuzeit, tempo und intensität stimmen überein.
als domorgelkenner sage ich zu allen besserwissern:
eine so grosse orgel mit dieser akustik lässt eine schnellere musikfolge nicht zu..
anubier 3 months ago
@mihihi What, as in it is not as fast as how the pianists play it? You have to keep in mind that we organists have to deal with acoustics which sometimes hang around for like seven seconds once a note as been sounded. If you play in an building with alot of acoustic such as Köln Kathedral at prestissimo, the piece would not make any sense at all because it will be all a blur of noise.
music88loverable 3 months ago 2
that is your tempo feeling in a toccata?? joke?
mihihi 5 months ago
listen to those acoustics... it sounds like it's being played at the bottom of the sea
paranoid711 8 months ago
@Steinweg100
hehe...I experienced the same think when I played Bach-Gounod Ave Maria on wedding in chatedral...there is no delay on 1st and 2nd manual, but 3rd!...delay of 1sec!!...hard to keep concetration but everything went fine at the end.......I playing Widor Toccata too...pretty easy but effectively peace
gorunlove 9 months ago
@gorunlove I entirely agree with you! All the drama, too, is beautfully clear: definition...mmmm, I remember playing an organ, which had a terrible delay....it was the Widor Tocatta, I was all of fourteen, not an organist, nor had I played that organ before; my friend signalled for me to keep going; I could do nothing but not dare to listen and play on HA!!
Steinweg100 11 months ago
haha...you make me lough...put a piano in that chatedral and play this piece...I don't think that you will play in original tempo because of acoustic....I think that is pretty nice tempo and you can hear everything whats happeninig inside compared with so high-performace piano version where you can't hear anything else but pile of sound
gorunlove 1 year ago
The videos are nice, but this piece is certainly being played awfully slowly! Are the various organs in the cathedral interconnected, or are we hearing only the organ hanging off the triforium wall?
JGCarillonneur 1 year ago
This is awesome! Thank you so much for all your fantastic videos!
Organistcomposer21 1 year ago