Crossbows vs Compound Bows - PART 2

This is a simple 2 part video comparing two functional set-ups on hunting bows, one a crossbow and the other a modern compound bow. Part 1 has operational demo and data. Part 2 has a practical based narrative. Neither of these are studio show bows but are truly field equipment. The time covered was inadequate to coven this subject in any depth so these are really just scratching the surface. Comments are more than likely disabled for this video. Not to be unfriendly but this subject almost always draws some of the worst in a very small, but very loud, segment of archers who simply hate what they dont understand.

Category:

Sports

Tags:

• Tenpoint
• Stealth
• Accudraw
• Mathews
• Drenalin
• Superslam
• Axis
• Easton
• Duravane
• Muzzy
• Innerloc
• Blazer

[mannr100]

To be honest I'm 16 and I can cock a rifle crossbow quickly, but bows are more versatile because you can add a string to the arrow

[rldel149]

@mannr100 - I accept your word but in a "hunting" scenario, movement in the stand and noise as well as safety are/should be considerations. The reality is crossbows are just loud klunky sounding devices compared to vertical bows (generally speaking).

Ultimatly, [imho] people should shoot what they like for the full collection of reasons: noise, accuracy, weight, maneuverability, price, maintenance, age/physical factors, local regulation/club rules, pride, etc.

[Lyecdevf]

Help me understand this?! As you have specified the crossbow arrow lose traction much faster. So you can not shoot as far as with a bow. I know I am right about that because I asked around but what I do not understand is that with a crossbow you have a scope while with the bow you do not. I figure it should be reverse since it would be more helpful to use a scope with a weapon that shoots further. I am afraid I would be less accurate with out a scope on a weapon.

[rldel149]

@Lyecdevf - I'll approach it another way, crossbows and bows are both deadly no doubt but different right. Different advantages and disadvantages. A typical lever gun has a big round or hog-nose bullet and simply won't hold as tight of groups as clip fed rifles w/balistic tips. Just in general it holds true. Banging nose-to5ail doesn't help aerodynamics. It doesn't they aren't effective systems - just different. IMO, bolts temd less accurate because of length etc.

[rldel149]

@Lyecdevf - I'll approach it another way, crossbows and bows are both deadly no doubt but different right. Different advantages and disadvantages. A typical lever gun has a big round or hog-nose bullet and simply won't hold as tight of groups as clip fed rifles w/balistic tips. Just in general it holds true. Banging nose-to5ail doesn't help aerodynamics. It doesn't they aren't effective systems - just different. IMO, bolts temd less accurate because of length etc.

[rldel149]

Please everyone don't be put off by what I am going to say the real issue with crossbows is simple human nature. They shoot relitivly easy and flat while still being hunting effective that the AVERAGE user simpply doesn't practice like a compound hunter does leading to human error such as wind drift and elevation miscalculations or pushing it too far. Deer will sure jump a crossbow string much faster than a compound. It doesn't mean they escape unharmed. Loud noises and long distances=bad shots

[MrIrish1969]

Shorten vanes to 2" on arrow, just like for compounds, makes it more accurate at longer ranges for xbows. You have to practice with either type of bow, if you think your going to pick it up and go hunting without putting in the work, i hope you dont hunt around me. Crossbows have to be waxed, string and cables alot, you dont do that and you get snapped strings and cables. Being able to use a scope is an advantage. I own a barnett predator, with a hawke sr scope on it. Its is a beast.

[petacavanagh]

Which is best for hunting? Taking into account, speed of reload, range, power and silence? I want one but I'm not sure which to go for, the crossbow seems to have double the tensile strength of a bow? And what ARE the effective ranges of the 2, in general?

[isaacdylansainz]

which one ends up cheaper in the long run?

[AnglesM888]

What is the name of your crossbow? Thanks :-)

[Coyotehunter2011]

Very nice video you have here. I shoot a compound myself just because i get more enjoyment out of it. I'm glad to see you are not biased toward one particular type of bow and this can really help out a beginner getting into the wonderful sport of archery.

[PortugalCarp]

Great couple of videos, thank you for putting them up. I for one am grateful for cross-bows. Due to an accident some years back I just have not got the upper body strength to draw and then hold for a minute or more any compound bow above a 40Lber, even one with an 80% let off. With a cross-bow, thankfully, I can still practice archery.

[PortugalCarp]

Great couple of videos, thank you for putting them up.