The Beach Boys "The Smile Sessions" Review
Uploader Comments (culturetease)
Top Comments
-
I understand that your given an opinion but some of what you are saying is not factual. Brian Wilson, Mark Linnett or Alan Boyd did no re-recording on this box set. What you are hearing is from the actual session tapes.
As for being a completeist, than listen to the 2004 release "Brian Wilson Presents Smile" which is the definitive version of the "idea" of what SMiLE was supposed to be.
All Comments (47)
-
Glad to see that you actually like the album but you could benefit from doing your home work a little more throughly before you do reviews as your knowledge on this subject is somewhat erratic all the way down to nonsensial.
`Smile``not having the same legendary status as `Pet Sounds``
You`ve got to be kidding
-
Do you even like music?
-
FUCK YOU
-
Listening to the way most of the songs segue into the others (as if it were supposed to sound like that) doesn't really sound like a random order to me. Brian and Van Dyke did after all write the songs as snippets and they could have been arranged in any order regardless of whether it was released in 67' or now. Also, Brian did technically finish the album, but on his own in 04', and again with Van Dyke's help, wrote lyrics to those unfinished songs you referred to.
-
look is a great song!
-
Do you enjoy being a walking stereotype?
-
i wish i was as cool as this guy thinks he is, i need to buy some glasses and a stupid fucking t shirt that only his friends think is mildly amusing. and blah blah blah smile....blah blah blah brian wilson.... blah blah blah... i have no fucking idea what i'm talking about. wankstain
-
its like not necessary to FRICKING RAMBLE AND REPEAT YOURSELF FOR THE ENTIRE FRICKING VIDEO! You think Your no music critic, and if you were, no one would listen to you!
-
Oh one other thing I know people are teasing you cos you look like a hipster from Williamsburg or whatever but if you really don't know where it is or what they're talking about you're fucking retarded.
Your a moron hipster and you have no clue what you are talking about. Do your research you dumb fuck. Go listen to some crappy electronic band from Williamsburg. You suck!
Milkshed20 3 months ago 7
@Milkshed20 well that was unnecessarily mean. I guess it takes some practice to not be immature.
wheres williamsburg?
culturetease 3 months ago
ur a raver but ur listening 2 smile? stick 2 stupid electro lol
NEWGUY562 3 months ago
@NEWGUY562 When did I say i was a raver? if I said that, it had to be in sarcasm. As a sidenote, typing with numbers as words doesn't help your argument.
culturetease 3 months ago
Its called the Smile 'Sessions'. Not the Smile Album. its a compilation of 'sessions' which justifies it's messiness.
SabrinaIannuzzi 3 months ago 2
@SabrinaIannuzzi Yeah i know it's called the Smile Sessions. Hence the, like, title of the video.
culturetease 3 months ago