周璇 - 天涯歌女

看了我好感動, 謝謝...

for those who don't know this version is first and "naive" movie version... it is supposed to be carefree and rough around the edges. the later version is slower, more emotional and sad. the version that people should hear is the studio version that appears on most audio collections.

she was incredible.

我国语(当时应该还没有普通话)不好,真听不出这些分别. 问题是她是否为了音效完美,后来故意放弃清晰的吐字? Sutherland,白雪仙等都常常用这样演绎的.

Classic. Li Xiang Lan version also very unique.

her son is raised up by 田漢

周旋是第一代影星
算是个时代代表
说她伟大是因为她代表了一个时代的艺术
是第一个偶像歌星
开辟了一个艺术的新时代
所谓承上而启下
是为艺术家

我并没有要贬低周璇的意思,但如果用你的理论把她这个音乐家与贝 多芬比,贝是英雄造时势,而周只能是时势出的英雄而已!

Her voice is bit low and coarse. But it suits Er Hu.

Tried Li Xiang Lang, is different.

Agree with Bmei39. She is unbeatable. Any remake can only be different but not better than her. This was her classic hit. She is definitely in a class of her own. Listen to her sing not jus this song but all her other hits and u will know why.