Can Muslims really beat their wives for disobedience?

"As to those women on whose part you see ill-conduct, admonish them, refuse to share their beds, beat them; but if they return to obedience, seek not against them means. Surely, Allâh is Ever Most High, Most Great."

Answered by Muhammad al-'Arifi

Category:

Howto & Style

Tags:

• islam
• jihad
• terrorism
• wife
• beating

[knottylazygrunt101]

you should NEVER beat your wife fuck this vid

[giro07]

@Morndenkainen lol its not tooth pick, its a kind of natural tooth brush from a type of tree in the arab states its called a miswaak, apparently I heard if you use a miswaak to brush your teeth, your memory increase...there is also more benefits but i remember that one : )

[sweetparvardi]

@muslimgiga; ... and instead simply tried 2 "pass the buck" on this entire subject [which I clearly was prepared 2 discuss respectfully + intelligently with u] 2 your favorite YT sheik. I've never heard your I. Hossain. He may be very good + wise, + I promise I'd watch his vid IF u 1st give me YOUR answers on wife beating, but loads of sheiks / imams r clearly loons !, + some justify "homicide bombing" of innocents, and OBL calls himself "sheik", so I "take it all with a grain of salt." : )

[sweetparvardi]

@muslimgiga; Now I'll wait 2 see if u "step up 2 the plate" on this, which's a term from American baseball, which u've maybe never played in Bangladesh, but u've probably played cricket ?, which is similar. Your Profile says u play basketball [which I love !], + tennis, and u're probably quite a nice + decent guy, and I respect Islam, + have a # of nice Muslim friends in US + abroad, and WASN'T "looking 2 pick a fight with u" ! But I was "annoyed" u dodged my straightforward, polite question...

[sweetparvardi]

@muslimgiga; PS : I also didn't ask YT Muslim wacko's favorite murderous "Imam Anwar Al Awlaki" this, I asked U ! Presumably U'VE seem I. Hossain's "brilliant" video, and 've absorbed its' great wisdom [Haha : )], so u should now be able 2 paraphrase all this 4 me, in your own words, no ? So tell me if your [frankly, dumb] "suicide" example's from Quran/Hadiths, or from your own head, or from I. Hossain, or where, + please give me at least 1 other "extreme" case requiring Islamic wife beating.

[sweetparvardi]

@muslimgiga So maybe your Prophet's wives always had dinner ready 4 him right on time, + were "perfect wifeys 4 him in every way" [Haha : ) ], so he didn't "need" to beat them. But apparently ordinary jerk Muslims have "need" to beat their "lazy" wives, so Allah put rules in 4 THEM, + I asked U about that, not Sheik I. Hossein, or "Sheik Osama Bin Laden", so DON'T PATRONIZE ME about my "misinterpretations": If U can't answer this yourself, you can't answer ! Just stop being a coward about it !

[sweetparvardi]

@muslimgiga @muslimgiga [Continued] "...only had the best to say about him", that's IRRELEVANT, since "Medicine's 4 the sick, not 4 the healthy !" Has it occured to u maybe Muhammed didn't beat his wives because [according to Islamic rationale 4 wife beating, I've seen on a # of YT videos] his wives didn't "need" beating. That is, e.g.: 1 Muslim man [an attorney], on a YT video, gives as a legitimate reason 4 wife beating that the wives refuse 2 have his dinner prepared 4 him on time.[Continued]

[sweetparvardi]

@muslimgiga : I "talk a lot" ? I wrote a 9 1/2 line reply, to your TEN line post, so YOU TALK MORE ! Also, my reply contained a polite / respectful inquiry, asking if your [ridiculous !] suicide example was from Quran or Hadiths, or instead was completely your own concept of "why Allah allowed 4 men beating their wives" in Quran, and u REFUSED 2 answer it. I'm not surprised, since the answer would of course EMBARRASS u !  If your Prophet didn't beat his wives, + his wives "only... [Continued]

[muslimgiga]

@sweetparvardi u talk a lot. If the prophet didn't beat his wives and his wives had only the best to say about him. Who are u to "expose" islam because of YOU misinterpreting this text? I suggest u to watch Sheik Imran Hossain explain this.

He tells the context and application of this verse. type wife beating Sheik Imran Hossain.

[sweetparvardi]

@muslimgiga : Is your suicide example from Quran or Hadith, or is it YOUR example ? I'm guessing it's YOUR'S, and it makes no sense !, in this context. because ANY world culture'd recognize need for physically restraining folks from suicide, until they're hopefully later in a better mental state, and won't harm themselves] ; It requires no "special compensation from Allah" to allow for that self-evident rational human behavior ! So please give ANOTHER "extreme example" justifying wife beating ?