Mozart Violin Concerto No. 3 in G Major, K.216, I. Allegro
Uploader Comments (fangruchang)
Top Comments
-
btw, perfect pitch isn't what allows someone to determine if a note is flat or not. perfect pitch is being able to identify the name of the note.
i don't have perfect pitch, but i can still tell if a note is in tune.
-
agree la... but what can you expect from a 11-year-old girl. She is still learning, and being able to play this so well is good enough to make people marvel at her and at her moral courage to stand up there to perform, even though if she makes pitch mistakes or accuracy mistakes. She gave all the effort she had in her performance and I could see it from the way she expressed her thoughts through the music and atmosphere created. So good job selina.
All Comments (42)
-
i was studying this concert when i was like 15 and i couldn't complete it, it was so hard to me (and i was like 4 years studying violin) some people are really talented! :) i love violin, and im in the "avarage" level y'know... u.u
-
I really AM jealous that I can't play like this. And what IS this thing about perfect pitch? 'Cause I'm preforming this in like a month and I'm not that great at it. I'm just trying to memorize the song and now I have to worry about perfect pitch? T.T
-
People really need to stop hatin on this girl. She's obviously worked hard and she's AMAZING for an 11 year old girl. You're just jealous that you can't play like this. Like seriously? She's able to do this and you guys are talking about her notes being "flat" or "sharp" or whatever? At least she's able to play this whole thing! I personally love this. So give her a damn break.
-
@amjc3 at such a young age, to play so well, it does not matter if she makes one minor mistake, which she didn't
-
the piece is fine, i just reckon the cadenza could take more practice.
-
not only good but shes also so frickin adorable.
-
I like her poise
-
serina i should say does not have exact perfect pitch. nobody can have perfect pitch. i practice 9 hours a day(not joking) and i still dont have perfect pitch. i agree perfect pitch does not mean anything about how good but i still dont think anyone should be bragging about anything.
-
well i think she's pretty good. i mean, she's not all all rushing. She's in tempo and the notes are fine... i used to use her video to practice for my audtion in like 2 months and now i dont use it anymore because well like i said, she's in tempo and the notes r fine and she's not rushing!!and i've been learnin this concerto for about 6 months i think?!? ok idk... lol...my comment doesnt have a point.
-
Just because you have perfect pitch (meaning you can identify a note when its played) doesn't mean that she doesn't either. And also, I'd like to see YOU play this as well as she did. I doubt you can, so just be quiet, because you probably can't do as well as she did. She's still young, and of course, can be improved, but she's really very good, so the only real reason for you saying that she isn't good is most likely because your JEALOUS. keep your jealousy to yourself.



much too legato in the opening section for my liking, not enough staccato.
the ricochet can also be worked on.
very good though. is she like 13 or something? 12?
joeisnice 3 years ago 3
11 on a 1/2 size violin. :)
fangruchang 3 years ago
Try "Watch in high quality."
It sounds more crisp that way.
fangruchang 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
In 0:55 or something she flinches as though she screwed up or something. I suspect that she hit the note flat (I have perfect pitch).
amjc3 3 years ago
Serina too, has perfect pitch. But it takes a lot more than that to play well. With the limited time she has for practicing violin, prioritizing on overall feeling is a wise decision, I think.
fangruchang 3 years ago