@crzxr A rather aggressive and condescending attitude, especially as we're not dealing with music of substance, only that of Sir Arthur Sullivan.
Before you suggest people need to apply to a "mental home" consider why you feel the need to show such disrespect and lack of logic towards people you don't even know.
to be pedantic, nobody knows what the "original" overture sounded like as Sullivan lost his manuscripts enroute to the new york premiere and had to rewrite much of the music ...
What the hell is all this shite about versions. I f your talking about the shit musical movie thing then you can't say you are familiar with the pirates of penzance at all.
Anyone with the barest familiarity with the opera, and of the slightest musicality, will recognize that this is a badly truncated and insensitively mangled version of the true overture; poorly cobbled parts of the proper overture. The extremely poor editing would never have been sanctioned by as good a composer as Sullivan, and anyone who seriously thinks this is the original overture in its complete form needs to consider applying to a mental home.
@crzxr A rather aggressive and condescending attitude, especially as we're not dealing with music of substance, only that of Sir Arthur Sullivan.
Before you suggest people need to apply to a "mental home" consider why you feel the need to show such disrespect and lack of logic towards people you don't even know.
wks1978 3 months ago
we used to play this in our brass band :)
MrSlayer42 3 months ago
please do your homework, if you are a true Sullivan fan, youll know this is edited, & it sounds llke D 'oyly Carte Opera Company on Decca too!!!!
danilo22uk 9 months ago
I played the trumpet solos in this piece; I was terrified! BUT ... I LOVED IT!!
tootintrumpet 1 year ago
Here's a more complete version, but I'm still not sure it has all the parts:
youtube.com/watch?v=oRy_qhHcnTs&feature=related
Kwprules 1 year ago
I wish that I could go back in time and hear all of Gilbert & Sullivan for the first time again.
mitchell36able 1 year ago
to be pedantic, nobody knows what the "original" overture sounded like as Sullivan lost his manuscripts enroute to the new york premiere and had to rewrite much of the music ...
lhrlyc 1 year ago
AMAZING!
lent77cv 2 years ago
What the hell is all this shite about versions. I f your talking about the shit musical movie thing then you can't say you are familiar with the pirates of penzance at all.
leporello56 2 years ago
Anyone with the barest familiarity with the opera, and of the slightest musicality, will recognize that this is a badly truncated and insensitively mangled version of the true overture; poorly cobbled parts of the proper overture. The extremely poor editing would never have been sanctioned by as good a composer as Sullivan, and anyone who seriously thinks this is the original overture in its complete form needs to consider applying to a mental home.
crzxr 2 years ago