Paul Hindemith: Heckelphone Trio op. 47
Uploader Comments (akseli88)
Top Comments
-
Not to be a pain, but perhaps it would be more accurate to say "all major orchestras can get ahold of a heckelphone." Man, I wish every orchestra in the world had one.
-
The heckelphone and the baryton oboe are not the same, the sonority is different.
All Comments (61)
-
@Trey5511 Not QUITE right. The Basset Horn goes down to F2 (the bottom space on the bass staff); the alto only goes down to G2 or G-flat2 in some cases. Not much of a distinction in terms of range, but they sound different from what I've read.
The contra alto (that is the correct name) is pitched an octave lower than the alto (apparently some can go lower).
There is also a B-flat contrabass.
-
is it midi-file?
-
THis is really great !! Thank you !
-
thanks a lot for letting to hear how the instrument sounds
What a useless debate! mine was a practical discourse! obvious that the two instruments are constitutionally different. Enjoy Hindemith rather than continue this discussion!
akseli88 6 months ago
The heckelphone and bass oboe are two very different instruments.
cellofellow1223 3 years ago
two VERY different instrument?????
I have already explained that, in my opinion, this difference is not so strong...
is not to be polemical: we talk about two different instruments, of course, but extremely similar, as the basset horn and the contralto clarinet, for exemple.
If they were so differents, don't you believe that their use would be more differentiated?
akseli88 3 years ago 2
@akseli88 Okay, to show you how wrong you are, here's the downward progression of pitch in the clarinet family from the Basset Horn to the Contralto: Clarinet in A -> Basset Horn in F -> Alto Clarinet in E-flat -> Bass Clarinet in B-flat -> Contralto Clarinet in EE-flat. See, the Basset horn is pitched an octave and one whole step apart from the contralto clarinet. not to mention contralto has a double octave key. they are different in virtually every way, save both being clarinets...
Trey5511 8 months ago
@Trey5511 I meant by "alto / contralto" something different from "contra-alto / sub-contralto". It's esay to misunderstandings... Then stop, please, I prefer to enjoy the trio!!!
akseli88 6 months ago