[Deleted Scene] Harry Potter and the deathly hallows Part 1 : Harry & Petunia
Top Comments
All Comments (190)
-
Why couldn't they keep this? It's wasn't even a minute long for crying out loud!!!
-
@iFenceU Too true.
-
i wish they had kept this
-
@ash356 J.K. Rowling said that that would be impossible, because any magic that could have gotten to Dudley would be destroyed by Uncle Vernon's genes
-
they should have kept this in the movie!
-
Darn it Yates, this is why we cant have nice things.
-
Petunia's reaction in the book was more realistic. Instead of saying all these things out of the blue, she looks as if she wants to tell Harry something before they leave, but holds back. You can't tell if she's going to miss him, if she regrets how she's treated him, or if she feels like she's losing a link to her sister. That wordless scene spoke more volumes of Petunia's character than this forced display of sentimentality.
-
This scene should be touching, but really, its just irritating. Petunia has never once shown any regret over her sister's death and she made it her mission in life to remind Harry constantly how worthless his parents were, and now all of a sudden, she's moving from her house and she confides in him something that completely contradicts 17 years of behavior towards him?
-
Kan een Nederlands iemand dit even vertalen, wat ze zeiden? Mijn Engels is zo slecht!
-
"I think that for one moment she trembled on the verge of wishing Harry luck; that she almost acknowledged that her loathing of his world, and of him, was born out of jealousy. But she couldn’t do it; years of pretending that ‘normal’ was best had hardened her too much."
—J. K. Rowling on what Petunia wanted to say shortly before the Dursley's departure.
Now this scene was too emotional and nothing like Petunia THANK GOD it didint make it into the film!!!!!
wow look she does have a heart!
bookmaniac2013 6 months ago 23
They should have kept this in :/
I always thought that in the books, they should have had Dudleys child going to Hogwarts in the end too :L Would have rounded everything off nicely.
ash356 7 months ago 17