Gustav Mahler. Das Klagende Lied. Complete & Illustrated Part 1 of 9
Uploader Comments (fiolspelare)
All Comments (11)
-
Mahler, the best!
-
@MusicInvestigation Yes, my friend: all the numbers, from 5 to 9 were done using only the great Haitink’s version. It is a shame he took for his interpretation the mutilated score. Fortunately, no one respects any more that cut done by the young Mahler -due to criticisms-, as everybody who tackles the work of Mahler now prefers to respect the great composer.
-
@ErnestoGomezSantan Do you know if Part 9 of 9 in this series is the Haitink or Boulez recording? And do you mean Haitink never recorded the first movement of this piece? And what do you mean it was removed by the author himself? By Mahler?
-
The first part is done by Pierre Boulez and the London Symphony Orchestra. The last two parts are conducted in a very mahlerian way by Bernard Haitink with his Concertgebow Orchestra. Haitink never recorded the first part, as it was sadly removed by the author himself.
-
Same question: who conducts, who plays and who sings?
-
Conductor/Orchestra?
Given that the story deals with fratricide, it is interesting to note that Mahler wrote the name Ernst in this score's margins. Ernst Mahler is the name of his recently deceased brother who died of illness in 1875. Gustav was close friends with his brother, a year his junior.
fiolspelare 1 year ago
I used several recordings, one of them is done by Pierre Boulez I think.
fiolspelare 1 year ago
A fascinating early work by GM showing his early Wagnerian influences (mostly Meistersinger as in the opening chorus but the curse is straight out of Alberich in the Ring!)
But alternately the use of material used in the later "Songs of a Wayfarer" where the fratricide victim-to-be is lying under a tree. (in the Wayfarer conclusion, the hero finds solace lying under a linden tree.) Without knowing more about it, though, since Mahler revised "Klagende" twice, it's not clear which use came first.
Eddy438 2 years ago
Yes, thank you for pointing out the Wayfarer reference. @Eddy438
fiolspelare 10 months ago