Opera: The Rhinegold, Part I, The Ring of Nibelung, Wagner
Top Comments
All Comments (48)
-
Uh yeah, but German isn't English. Ever tried to learn German? In its construction, German is closer to Latin than English--- has those pesky Cases, which you have to memorize and learn. Also, many, many words are quite different in German--- most of our words in Modern English came from the Normans, so they are Latin-based rather than Germanic. Anyway, take it from someone who lived in Germany and had to learn German quickly-- it's no picnic and major differences.
-
Wow. An english accent can sell anything.
-
@darkwolfdv most english speakers speak a language based on anglo saxon which is germanic
-
@matharoofmaths I know! I'm watching this as an assignment for a music class so I put up with the bad quality audio and weird "storyline," but the end was too much-and ridiculous.
-
@darkwolfdv; "Tolkien is a re-dresser of pre-existing folklore."
And so was Wagner. Wagner's "The Ring of Nibelung" made many changes to the original texts. Tolkien's re-dressing in his mythology is a very different story.
"And like I said, most English-speakers don't speak German and don't like opera so they are unaware of Wagner's previous genius work."
And what does that have to do with Tolkien's fiction? I like Wagner's Ring cycle. But that doesn't mean I have to falsely slam Tolkien.
-
You are incorrect. What I stated is correct. Tolkien is a re-dresser of pre-existing folklore. Whether it "moves beyond" or not, it is still a retelling of the same myths. And like I said, most English-speakers don't speak German and don't like opera so they are unaware of Wagner's previous genius work.
-
@darkwolfdv; Silly comments. Wagner based his Ring cycle on ancient Northern European mythology. Tolkien wrote his own version of these myths called "The Legend of Sigurd and Gudrun" which has recently published. But as for "The Lord of the Rings" this is Tolkien's work. It is not a retelling of a myth as with Wagner.'s Ring "The Lord of the Rings" touches on ancient mythology but then moves beyond that with a blend of various pagan and Christian ideas in an original story.
-
Informative, but rather dull. They should have let Anna Russell record it.
-
Nice
-
Never thought it would end up being a commercial :/



hahaha at 5:09 David's penis is blurred. gotta love the american prudishness. wimps!
show this to any European and he'll either laugh his ass off or stand speechless.
intigfx 3 years ago 15
This is great, especially the displaying of the Leitmotive!
ludowicovan 3 years ago 9